This message was deleted.
# _general
s
This message was deleted.
b
IGEL is a solid solution. They also have an IGEL community channel with customers and their support that contribute to it. Certainly will be one sided but still a great solution to look at and will help you with your pilot of that solution.
r
Nice. Do they offer something that can auto config the device . Like some sftp config file? Im trying not take out the need of manual configuration for our helpdesk. Looking to Auto launch desktop once the user logs in
b
Yup. You can organize the endpoints in the management console and apply different configs based on where they are. Think of it like group policy for thin client config
r
Ahhh nice man. So usb and auto launch is good as well? Im going to reach out to them to get a pilot. Sounds solid
n
We've been QA testing IGEL for a year now, and will be finally rolling it out in Prod for a POC in the coming months. IGEL's major advantage over literally everyone else is their software. It's the most configurable, IMO. I'm doing a lot of what you're asking about. Techs will be able to move the device into a folder in the management console, and it will pull down the entire config automatically. You can have all devices roll into a specific folder/config automatically, but you'll likely wind up wanting somebody to put the device into a specific folder based on their task. We're going to be using IGEL hardware (the new UD2-LX's) for a tap-to-desktop solution, and an Epic-only solution, where the providers will tap their badge to authenticate directly into our Epic EMR (via XenApp).
r
Ohh very nice guys i appreciate it very much.
I know u have usb devices in the health care. When i was in it. We had Phillip speeach mics, card readers, pin pads, scanners, and usb impravata badge in badge out. If you got all that working (or similar) igel is the way to go.
t
Avoid Dell/Wyse at all cost! Horrible support, mediocre performance. I'm surprised they are still in business.
👍 1
b
One of IGELs biggest customers is Indiana university health system. Guy who runs it is former CUGC leader but now they are a horizon shop. He’s in the IGEL slack
r
Tobias, i am surprised as well. If IGel is in health care that means they are solid. Health care in my experience had ao many usb devices. Optimize and generic usb devices.
n
Yeah, one of our workflows is going to be providers dictating into Epic via Dragon Medical 360 (or DMO if we ever switch), so they'll be plugging USB microphones and headsets into them. The only caveat here is that you're looking at generic USB redirection for all of this and not HDX audio. I worked with IGEL on this for weeks, and we couldn't get this working the way we have it on physical devices. Part of the issue is likely the fact that the Linux CWA is missing a number of features that's included in the Windows version.
IGEL has many clients in healthcare.
r
Ok so no usb optimzed devices, which if for hdx things as well. All Generic usb support? I am sure the cwa linux client will be updated soon to support teams. Oh are they ready on teams yet?
Curious how much more bandwidth it will consume?
n
I've only tested a half dozen USB microphones and some card readers, but all worked just fine in IGEL. I wouldn't hold out hope on Linux CWA changes. They aren't exactly motivated to do much there.
r
Gotcha, ill need to ask them about teams as well when i contact them next week.
n
I'm going to have to check my notes at work on Monday. I believe it's one or the other - HDX or Generic - for a device and not a combination of the two. We wanted both because PowerMic users need Generic for the buttons, and headset users can roll with either or. This reminds me of another issue we experienced with regards to the sound card in the IGEL. I'll definitely see if I can find notes on this on Monday.
r
Ok i appreciate it Nick
b
I believe there is a custom partition for teams so you can load it direct onto the iGel endpoint. I know there is a chrome one
r
I remember reading something on that
n
I do know that we disabled local audio on the IGEL in order to make our workflow work.
r
Oh i always say optimize usb support. Is the term HDX usb instead? Dont want to sound dumb lol
n
Yeah, one and the same.
BTW, IGEL has a huge Slack presence.
r
Ahh ok. I need to find that channel
n
r
Thanks again
n
If you join, you can see some of my earlier troubleshooting: https://app.slack.com/client/T8EKKMH51/C8FC01UNM/thread/C8FC01UNM-1563274938.055500
If Citrix ever adds the Connection Bar to their Linux Receiver/CWA client, I think this might be easier to accomplish (in my scenario).
Ray, do you guys run Imprivata at all, or plan on it?
r
I dont anymore, i moved away from health care and went to banking.
Which they still could but i doubt it
n
Okay, the reason I mention it is because in newer IGEL firmware releases, you're required to be on specific Imprivata version.
r
Dang looks like i need a invite for igel in slack
n
r
Nice. Thanks
d
+1 for Igel, we have hundreds, good management through their software. +1 for igel slack too. We use optimised and generic usb for different things. Auto-start is cushty, we use their appliance mode settings so users power on and the igel auto-browses to storefront website where they login and auto-launch whatever desktop they should get. They're not there on teams just yet, in terms of the full BCR and local teams installation on the igel, but i know they're working on it and we can expect it soon. They are also working on native controlup support in their os so we can monitor with controlup. If you're going thin client, they're right up there. We've been a customer for almost 10 years. The price has increased quite a lot... and is still going up..... almost price comparable with a cheapo dell windows machine these days, which has us questioning our next refresh. But really, they are good and definitely worth a PoC, trial etc.
A big advantage imho, from a Citrix perspetive, is they use the official CWA for Linux, rather than eg Wyse's custom-made thing that is missing most of the recent Citrix advances. eg. EDT.
b
HP also modifies the CWA so it differs from what Citrix releases. The nice thing with iGel is you can use different versions of CWA per config in case there is an issue or specific feature you need. Also you can use existing hardware and load the iGel OS on it or use their UD pocket which lets you boot from USB.
n
Yeah, I imaged a few of our old Lenovo devices just as a demonstration of OS Creator. Worked nicely, and is a good solution if you want to reuse the hardware you’re attempting to replace. IIRC, we’re paying under $300 for a brand new UD2, so we’re at least starting off on their hardware.
t
To @David Inglis’s point yes, the custom OS Dell has on their Wyse units often went a year before any updates were released, if ever, and the ones we had at NAU never got any past a certain point, hence as correctly pointed out not EDT nor even UDP support! The units became bricks. Might also take a look at Stratodesk's offerings, which are solid and flexible, but you'd still need an end point unit s they only do software. A Raspberry Pi at this point might be an option if Citrix Virtual Desktops is the route you want to take, but am not sure if the USB support/performance might be a limiting factor or not.
s
IGEL are good but support is mediocre. They are growing so fast and can’t keep up on the support side. Thank goodness for their slack community!
t
Same could be said for Citrix support, which has been very spotty as of late alas. 🙁
b
#truth @Tobias Kreidl
c
I am the unicorn here we actually went with Dell wyse, the hardware is better the. Igel and I didn’t want yet another system to maintain. Wyse is cloud based and it does what we need which is vdi.
They are not as flexible as igel, but they have the latest workspace and zero touch is easy. Use stuff seems to work but only doing basic things.
d
We sanity-checked early last year and got a few Wyse in on test, feedback was the graphical performance (using XA win2016) was noticeably better than our igel units. Can’t remember model numbers off hand. They didn’t have the then-latest CWA as Citrix don’t make one for wyse-os, dell pick and choose Citrix features and brew their own client. That is what we were lead to believe anyway (not by igel lol!). So - horses for courses and OP should definitely PoC a few :)
n
Before we settled on IGEL, we tested the RX-HDX (managed via Stratodesk), HP t630 (HP’s management system is trash), Dell, and I think a Viewsonic Pi device. While I liked Stratodesk’s management, the hardware wasn’t enough for us. IGEL has updated both the UD2 and UD3, so you’re getting more powerful hardware now in a slick looking unit.
FWIW, IGEL has a number of clients who purchase thin clients from their contracted vendors and then image them with IGEL’s own OS. We were prepared to do that with HP’s thin clients if forced to use HP, but I was allowed to roll with my own choice.
c
I here ya.. igel management interface is better. I have Rtme 2.8 and workspace 1910 I think with Dell. We almost went with Lenovo on igel. But getting igel from the factory seemed questionable. Good news is we can always reimage them with igel if needed.
b
I haven’t used them in a couple years but I will agree that Dell was simple to use and stable. Just depends on what your driving factor is. If you want a true zero client I would say dell has a solid product. Flexibility and management go to IGEL.
👍 1
c
That was my thought, we have enough crap to support, Dell is just east especially for Citrix basic stuff and is cloud hosted. So far so good.
t
WDM that Dell uses to manage the Wyse units is decent, but nowhere as flexible as the management systems from Igel or Stratodesk. Stratodesk support -- for me at least -- has been consistently good. WIth either Stratodesk or Igel, you can manage a wide vraiety of end point hardware of your choosing, provided of course they meet the particular vendor's criteria.
r
I need to test all these out. I need to be able have good video and audio for teams when the time comes. I cant deal with crap usb support either. I also dont want to deal with late patching cycles on windows thin clients.
Thanks for all the advice
👍 3
Nick i just went through and read you iGel troubleshooting. I had to read it like 5 times for it to click. So based on what read it doesn't look like you have the control over generic usb and optimized usb at the same time. You headset needed to be generic and mics to be optimize it cant work. Pick one or the other if it works. Then you disabled mic and audio redirection to make them show up as generic, but no sound work work in the session. Until you tell them to leave the mic unplugged? Man what a situation. Being able to so generic and optimized like a windows cwa is a big deal for me.
n
That sounds like the issue in a nutshell. I’m still going to check my notes at work to see if something is missing there. I’m hopeful that there’s a resolution to this sometime in the future.
r
The whole Generic vs optimize usb deal still throws me for a loop at times.
b
You aren’t the only one
r
Lol i have to read it like once a month to make sure im not going crazy. I guess the worst thing is more me is i have to test and figure out when one works the best for optimized or generic. Unless there is a hardware sheet thats updated. But looks like the linux workspace app is different in these setups.
n
It’ll all come down to your workflow. If you’ve got devices where only headset users will access, you can roll with optimized audio. If you want anyone to be able to use it, you’re basically looking at one or the other. If you manage to find a way to get both working in a consistent manner, definitely report back.
🧵 2
r
Will do man.