This message was deleted.
# _general
s
This message was deleted.
n
Which HP models were terrible? Nothing else to add, but minor hijack for anyone else - some Citrix client-side offloading only available with Windows clients. E.g. MS Teams.
v
Windows clients seem to be more feature rich. But a pain to manage/reimage. We had Dell 7020 - losing connection to management server, losing “lockdown” settings. Someone had to troubleshoot them on site to reconnect them back to the management server. From security standpoint you have to have appropriate patching and AV. I managed to brick 5 TCs while reimaging. Updated image from Dell had different behaviour making our reg hacks unusable. I was pretty happy to have them out and replaced by Dell wise 5070.
d
Besides for some very unique use cases I don’t see why one might want to run Windows on thin clients. Basically you give away most of the benefits of a thin client approach and probably could just stick with your legacy Windows fat clients.
n
They’re cheaper. @dready
t
Either Igel or Stratodesk solutions are rock solid and Linux-based. I ran Dell thin clients for over a decade and it was no fun; after they took over Wyse firmware updates were rare ann few between and for some models -- only a few years old -- then never, with the recommendation to just buy new Dell thin clients. No thank you. HP performance was at the time even worse. Depending on what power you need, maybe even a Raspberry Pi - based client might be an option? That is if you don't need to stream super fast or large-format videos; for everything else, I thought they worked great, even with dual monitors.
d
That I really doubt @Nathan Shaw - don’t get me wrong, I love thin clients, but never would deploy Windows based thin clients, if not absolutely needed. Modern Linux thin clients is the way to go in my opinion.
👍 2
n
Nah cheaper was regarding your comment thin Win vs fat Win. At purchase time, thin cheaper than fat. They probably wouldn’t exist otherwise.
k
not if you repurpose existing fat clients @Nathan Shaw, which @dready probably meant
d
even when you look at new hardware you will get commodity fat client hardware cheaper than thin client hardware these days
k
also true
cheap Intel NUC7 or 8 with an i3 for instance
cheaper than most TC's
a
We actually have all older iGel linux based clients now and started replacing w/ Clearcube Linux based (stratodesk) and have worked pretty well. the big sticking point is we've been burned w/ Citrix not offering some features for Linux that they do for Windows (or they do but its way later). Specifically right now theres been a huge push for video conferencing with Teams which goes back years (before teams of course). The session reliability on a Windows client is helpful too but not as big of a deal. We have 30 10zig windows clients now for a specific group in the field ( i wont bore you with why) and they've been pretty easy to work with so far. As for Windows updates so far we've just used a script they/microsoft uses to run on a schedule to disable the write filter, reboot, update, enable write filter. AV we were hoping to go w/ Defender since its already there and can be updated monthly. I'm with most of you that i would very much prefer to stick w/ Linux for the simplicity but its getting more difficult to work with Citrix when a linux client is involved because they are very quick to say they can't help due to the closed architecture of them. so anyways was just curious for those of you who do use them which management have you found to be best. HP's management is what i meant was terrible...clients were pretty solid
t
When you add in the VDI software and licensing, over time it's typically at least as expensive as a low-end thick client. If cost is all you care about, a thin client may well not be the right option for you. They do have their plus points, absolutely, but each environment needs to evaluate its needs to make a good decision whether to go thin or thick. And, yes, repurposing old PCs is another option; in such a case, look carefully at the server side and its capabilities.
n
i3 NUCs are good price - how do they perform?
k
More than enough for Citrix
We use these for testing our platform all the time - can easily do 60 fps @ 1080P, would even do 60 fps @ 4K, depending on the model (needs to support 60 Hz @ 4K)
I have a video somewhere of 4K gaming @ roughly 60 fps using Citrix in a LAN, using an Intel NUC7i3BNK
t
A Pi 4 will actually beat a low-emd NUC i3 in performance, but for most things, both are adequate. Getting 60 FPS for 4k videos is supposedly supported for one monitor on the Pi 4, but not if both HDMI ports are used (it then falls to 30 FPS for 4k, each).
k
Well @Tobias Kreidl; it's still not officially supported, right?
with the whole ctxh264.so decoding
but I agree with you, if you want dirt cheap, fps is not an issue and you can go without features specific to Windows, RPi4 with Stratodesk is the way to go
t
The Pi 4is actually supported now and NComputing has a produt supporting Citrix Workspace Hub that you can order now. I believe Stratodesk is the endpoint management.