This message was deleted.
# _general
s
This message was deleted.
j
We've had this debate - don't do exclusions!
⤴️ 2
👍 2
d
Ok, well we're having LTE connected devices trough VPN, i guess il just need to prevent it from syncing when on a metered connection.
Indeed, i'm talking about Windows 10 mobile devices. I haven't specified this. Sorry
j
Mobile as in laptops?
👍 1
d
Yes. Its just that they go in the jungle. We've got around 250 lte connected laptops, used by nurses to do homecaring for patients.
j
FSLogix needs good networking connectivity - but I am assuming you'd use the offline mode when in the jungle 🙂
j
Physical machines use cloud cache. First location local and next remote.
⬆️ 1
d
Thats exactly what i'd like to do. Metered Connections are well managed in W10. Even when on VPN, it knows i'm on a metered connection. Anyways, i first need to make it work, i've had weird troubles in january when trying to make it work. It was working great to sync settings, but it was killing my redirected folders.
j
You don't really need redirected folders when using FSLogix
⤴️ 1
d
@Jarian Gibson, thats what i've done in my tests, putting a local CDP location. It was working, but its just like it wasnt liking the "Offline mode" .
@James Rankin, well we have some Citrix Desktops too (TS). We want users to be able to see their files on it. But we also need to seperate W10 settings and WS2029 settings. So we can't use the same VHDs for both. Thats why we need redirected folders seperated from fslogix
j
OneDrive FTW
d
Sure OneDrive, but we're still on premise, fully. Its going slowly in governments (the switch to Azure and 365).
k
@Dany Bouchard are you using cloud cache? This is the only way you'll be able to go offline with FSLogix. I use this connection string: type=smb,connectionString=\\localhost\Profile$;type=smb,connectionString=\\fileserver\fslogixcc$
👍 1
I am also using the latest FSlogix public preview
j
Public preview looks really promising for Cloud Cache
d
@Kasper Johansen Yeah i've tried it. It worked well with cloudcache. JUST for the settings. But the Redirected folders get killed after enabling it. I don't really know why.
k
Yes, don't use redirected folders :)
That defeats the purpose of FSLogix
d
@Kasper Johansen just like i said up here "Well we have some Citrix Desktops too (TS). We want users to be able to see their files on it. But we also need to seperate W10 settings and WS2019 settings. So we can't use the same VHDs for both. Thats why we need redirected folders seperated from fslogix"
@Kasper Johansen If you're telling me there's no way to make it work with redirected folders(with offline mode) in parallel. We'll just switch back to our tests with Citrix UPM.
Seriously, thanks for responding. I was feeling so alone with this thing. Your knowledge helps me.
k
I would use OneDrive with Know Folder Move for Documents and Desktop, and then let FSLogix handle the rest
d
@Kasper Johansen, ok good. I like the idea. But we don't have one drive. Our government isn't ready, for security reasons.
So it will be Citrix UPM. 🤷🏻‍♂️
m
we just moved from redirected folders to onedrive known folder move and sharepoint for our former file shares, It’s going ok, but onedrive is seriously slow to kick off on first login
👍 1
fslogix does not like folder redirection at all, it just doesn’t play nice in any environment I’ve tried it in.
😢 1
d
@Mike Streetz (O_P), I'll drop the towel then.
m
I was trying redirected desktops and start menus and running into all sorts of issues qith things just not showing up
what I’m seeing is that once you see the performance benefit of moving to block level instead of file level, you try to get rid of anything in your vdi environment that needs to do a network file operation beause it’s just so slow.
d
@Mike Streetz (O_P) That's exactly what I've been trough. Let's use Citrix UPM, until we have one drive. One day.
m
UPM and onedrive do not play nice either
d
@Mike Streetz (O_P) Yeah I don't mind. We don't have OneDrive lol haha. But it's good to know.
m
UPM hates the metadata folders and doesn’t remove them on logout a lot of the time
leading to corrupt profiles
or locked sessions
Could be something I’m doing wrong with exclusions, but it’s been bad for us which is why we went full fslogix
d
So lets say this (i'm trying to wrap it up). If you want folders like Documents, Desktop, Pictures, outside of the FSLogix Profile container, you would need Onedrive, because classic folder redirections would not work at all(thats what i want to do). Its also recommended to put all of these folders (Documents, Desktop, Pictures,etc.) into the FsLogix Profile Container. Thumbs up if you agree.
🤔 1
👍 1
m
I mean it should technically work with redirection, I’ve just never done it successfully, but that’s just me.
d
@Mike Streetz (O_P) No one in here for now seem to have done it. Thats why i'm writing this. I'm searching for someone having it in prod on W10. I need FsLogix to only manage Appdata.. only that. Nothing else, and i've had the same problems you've had. Locked profiles, corruptions, etc.
m
@Mike Streetz (O_P) Are you on mobile devices or VDI ? Dany talks about w10 Laptop that needs to go offline or over LTE and wants to have profiles on Network when online (UPM style or FSlogix) My understanding of FSlogix is that it should work with cloud cache but it doesn't.
👍 1
m
I’ve never got cloud cache to work either
I’ve only ever tried it on vdi
My gut reaction is you will spend a lot of time trying to get this working and it’ll never do what you want
👍 1
d
@Jarian Gibson @Kasper Johansen, How have you got the public preview? Maybe i could find something interresting in it. Thanks
However some have reported that they have never received any software
d
@Kasper Johansen But its 2004, it's an old version (kidding! :))
k
😛
j
Folder Redirection should be taken out into the woodshed and shot. It is an ancient technology trying to solve the problems of roaming profiles.
😄 1
You want FSLogix to only manage APPDATA? Wrong technology, although you could use Office365 Container and just swap the Outlook location to %APPDATA% instead and that would roam your AppData in a VHD. Maybe frx.exe can also do custom redirections - haven't tried that way though
m
@James Rankin have you successfully used FSlogix with cloud cache/offline mode ? It is the part that doesn't work well yet.
We are still talking about laptops that goes online and offline but that we want to have profiles on network
j
Yep latest version seems better. It never worked previously, but it does now. I only have it in DEV currently though but they are real live users on it
👍 1
m
I am currently trying to do that with UPM and folder redirection and i thought it would work better than previous FSlogix versions... but for now i am struggling with existing profiles on user laptops that do not stay in place. Some get deleted besoin of NTuser problem.
with what i hear from you i will try the latest version of fslogix to see if it's better
j
Here's what I always think about Folder Redirection - USERPROFILE - redirected to VHD DOWNLOADS - local, discarded at logoff (excluded from VHD) DOCUMENTS - OneDrive or other EFSS solution, cached into VHD PICTURES - follow the Documents folder VIDEOS - follow the Documents folder MUSIC - follow the Documents folder DESKTOP - redirected into OneDrive with Known Folder Move (or mount it up to a separate VHD using Office365 Container with a customized path, or frx.exe) Everything else (APPDATA, LOCALAPPDATA, CACHE, COOKIES, FAVORITES, etc.) is all captured into the VHD If you wanted different operating systems with the same IE Favorites or something then you could simply use something like UE-V to save the settings and inject them into both VHDs Aside from this I can't see a lot of use cases where you would need to use folder redirection in any way. Happy to listen to use cases though because I'm thinking about writing up another bloggy rant about Folder Redirection and I'd like to take everyone's situations into account rather than just my own as usual :-)
👍 1
⤴️ 1
k
Try the latest FSLogix Apps version and use Cloud Cache it works
I would read that rant James 😄
👍 1
j
I already did one but I think I need to be a bit more accommodating of other use cases
👍 1
k
One can never write to many rants about Folder Redirection 😄
d
@James Rankin I guess i'm not alone stucked in the past without Onedrive. 😛. Thanks for the attention.
m
Do a rant on redirected start menus in FSLogix with custom XMLs on a network share 😛
l
May be i am missing something here regarding folder redirections.. we use fslogix with no exclusions, but use folder redirects via appsense config, my view is this keeps the user data segmented from fslogix and if the fslogix container gets corrupted (which happens occasionally) then all i have to do is blow away the container and appsense and folder redirects just reapply the users data. I should say this is all on non persistent PVS delivered win10 VDI. Is there a reason why I shouldn’t do this? In my experience fslogix is good, but not yet consistent to rely on completely
k
I have, in five years, only ever seen one corrupt FSLogix Profile Container, and that was because UPM and FSLogix were both trying to create a user profile. FSLglogix is very consistent and if you experience regular corruption, something is not right in your setup.
l
Perhaps “corrupt” is an over statement, i mean an app may stop working and the only way to resolve is to delete and recreate the fslogix container. With Folder Redirects we can easily remove containers without worrying abut the user data, which seems a more efficient way to control data?
j
Never seen that happen. Folder Redirection is the devil's spawn. Just use EFSS location for Documents and let everything else follow it (Pictures, Videos, Music). You lose the container, resync the data
👍 1
If your app stops working delete the app data from the container not the whole thing. It's probably some sh*tty cache conflict causing it. Find it, exclude it. Removing the whole container is the sledgehammer-nut approach
👍 1
l
Sure, we had a lot of issues with the exclusions xml at the beginning (there was a crowd sourced github exclusions file which I chucked out as it caused so many issues) - have now come round to your idea, expressed elsewhere of removing optimizations and just allowing native fslogix. That said, my main concern is not having to back up fslogix as they take up so much storage (and backup storage), so guess I always wanted to ensure that user data is held externally from the container. But think you may be right with FR, as on as documents and desktop folder can be stored outside,the rest can resynced