This message was deleted.
# _general
s
This message was deleted.
m
a
This is all well known to me.. I guess what I am trying to say, with all the offloading packs installed and configured, and all the upgrades, infra, storage etc... that are required to support all different use cases, and with all "known limitations" for video/audio offloading etc... are we seeing a trend where the balance is tipping towards "just buy a laptop"
m
Ah, got it... Curious what others will have to say
👍 2
j
I personally think we have been seeing that trend for a while now - VDI is rarely going to win from a cost perspective, it does offers loads of other benefits, BUT if those benefits are no longer the primary focus point for companies, then going back to physical devices with modern management and security is pretty common and appealing ....really depends on the org and use case
💡 2
👍 1
d
Also depends on what the overall strategy is. How the company wants its users to consume data. If the company wants to keep its data within its controlled perimeter or if it is ok for every users to store and work on data locally. Another example is how far users are from the company data... etc.
💡 1
a
On the other hand, with more and more apps becoming cloud/web based, it's not too important whether the app is close to the data center or/and the database....
c
VPN is seen as easy. It's also way more insecure but unfortunately many companies don't care about that until it's too late. If you're selling VDI as a cost control mechanism then IMO you're doing it very wrong.
💡 1
a
@CTXMike So is mainly the security aspect that wins the case for VDI/RDSH in your opinion?
l
Security and Compliance but flexibility. Its not one rule for all, also when we say VDI I am assuming we are talking single/multi user OS. Multi user OS can be cheaper that traditional physical devices over time and if managed correctly can be a very simple and easy solution to consume.
💡 1
I see the trend you are talking about though. However, during these times what I have also seen is the flip side. Users being asked to login with their own device, an ipad, a chromebook and given the flexibility to consume business desktops/apps without worrying about the device.
💡 1
c
Security tends to be the top, there's also a lot to be said for standardization of the desktop environment. When someone calls tech support about something that's happening inside a VDI, the helpdesk knows that all VDIs are identical and should behave the same. Cuts the time to resolution way down. Also the ability to get to that same workload from whatever client device I want to. I don't have to care about the endpoint at all, as long as it has a Citrix client (or an HTML5 browser) it can access the same workload.
💡 1
👍 1
a
I agree, scalability, flexibility, security and support. What's happening in some orgs is that, if money is a close call between the two options, and UX (especially with collaboration tools VDI limitations) is not great on RDSH/VDI, an easier option for management is to buy laptops! They will suffer down the line but unfortunately they can't see it coming...
c
yeah unfortunately if the environment isn't designed to support collaboration effectively then it will definitely be a black eye on the VDI side. A lot of orgs just plain didn't do any real remote collaboration in normal operations and were unfortunately caught off guard.
👍 1
a
Cost wise, VDI needs: Infra servers, storage,workload hosts, monitoring solution, profile and office management solution, Windows licenses, Citrix Licenses, thin clients cost and licensing, network, DR. Whereas laptops need: existing SCCM, good network design and a laptop!
👍 1
c
And a good VPN solution, and a good firewall with IPS/IDS capabilities, threat prevention, perhaps DLP as well, and strong authentication. Forget the security stuff and you're a sitting duck.
👍 1
a
Yup, problem is many security agents/tools are also imposed on VDI workloads and kills performance...
Just to clarify here, I am playing devils advocate here to enrich the discussion 😉
c
Sure, but on the flip side you've only got to tune your host based protections on the VDI once versus the perf hit on every client device. Also there are options for things like hypervisor based threat prevention. Also keep in mind a lot of the network stuff should be in place already at the datacenter from a firewall/web filtering/etc standpoint.
💡 1
l
VDI requires a balance in all things, its requires close consideration and thorough design work to be a good fit. In my view though its no easier pushing out laptops and effectively securing them. 50% of the discussions are similar and the challenges the same.
💡 2
s
Our company is in this boat. We are in serious discussion to drop Citrix/RDSH for this exact reason. Optimization packs are only for a handful of products out there and ignore Mac users. (Teams, zoom, S4b, ect) When they are supported it seems they are half baked, lack full functionality, need troubleshooting, and have to much client admin overhead for machines not connected to the domain.
💡 1
l
There are plans to address all this with the newer workspace app releases but I do hear you on this front.
s
@Leee Jeffries How would you even do that in the client with out Citrix being inundated with multiple partners?
k
@Martin Zugec question for you. We have an audio/vid solution that is not optimized for Citrix, what would you suggest in regards to that? We have got them using it locally during this period, but need a way to get them using it on our VDI in some form or another.
l
The optimisations for real-time communication will be built in to the workspace as, the embedded browser is already used for content redirection. @stormlight
⤴️ 1
@King ston you'll need real-time audio enabled as a minimum, to handle the video you'll really require graphics cards in servers with that being offloaded to the client. @Ray Davis wrote a great blog on real time audio I believe. Would love him to chip in too.
💡 1
d
Interesting discussion and most has already been said, so not much for me to contribute here other than to concur on the shift towards physical devices as opposed to virtual that I've observed in a few companies due to the perceived shortcomings within the virtual space. Interesting times for WVD, RDSH, Citrix et al...
💡 2
r
Thanks Leee. Interesting conversation.... I know from experience VDI and video/audio is at times challenging. I see it at my company where VPN and audio just works. Yea I must admit, it frustrating for me. Because the first thing they say is why can Citrix do that right out of the box. But thats the folks, who dont truly understand the Citrix Citrix/RDSH. I have tested, Bluejeans, Avaya, Skype, Zoom, and Webex. They all work really well if you have the complete solution. But there are times, you just cant get the complete solution. For any situation where you cant get audio optimizaed over a 3party app such a VDI connector. The best option is to use UPD for audio. I have tested this and it does help. Sometimes over really bad networks, It will not. But this will help you for that. I struggled to get avaya to work with UPD without the Avaya vdi connector. for a Citrix RSDH setup it was choppy and very diffcult to get working. But for a Citrix VDI desktop it worked great for me. I think that because of the Network being dedicated to the VDI vs the RSDH network is more of a shared solution. Just my thoughts. https://citrixadvice.blogspot.com/search/label/UDP%20over%20Audio%20for%20Citrix%20VAD
a
Thanks @Ray Davis it's all the ifs and buts that weakens the case for VDI.... It seems that all new features are made with physical machines in mind and then VDI/RDSH is trying to catch up with costy half solutions... the lack of MacOS support for offloading also negates the slogan Any device, anywhere, anytime... Hopefully those issues will be addressed soon...
k
Thanks Leee and Ray We are in this exact predicament. Our VDI is running fine but cannot handle our new audio/video solution( not Citrix to blame, it's probably more our comm solution) So now we are working ways on how to move away from VDI but not Citrix as whole. A VPN always type solution with netscaler and then publishing apps to the local machine is what we are thinking of doing.
r
What audio provider are you using?
k
Fuze is the system we are using for video and audio conferencing. Audio is not bad, video maxes CPU instantly.
r
Never used Fuze. But I can tell you from experience, when you dont have the VDI connector. The CPU is will smashed. Becuase it cant offload to the end point.
k
I'll look into that sharpish. Is that part of your blogpost above?
r
The Blog is around trying to optimze audio over UPD when you dont have the neccassary connectors.
When I say VDI connector, I am using it a a Gerneric term. Each vendor the has audio/Video software typically has something for Citrix. Example Sype RTME, Teams Built in to workspace now, BLUEJean VDI connector. AVAYA equalnox vdi connector.
c
Yeah, there's no way around software video encoding slamming the server CPU. If you don't have a provider that has a VDI style install you're gonna have a bad time. Along those lines though, please make some noise with your reps/SEs about things like OSX Teams offload support or other providers that don't work yet. Quickest way this stuff changes is based on customer requests.
k
Oh sorry, the connector is developed for specific solutions, am I right in saying? So as we don't have one, we would have to go through other avenues to get better performance.
r
Yea the connector woudl be developed by the software vendor.
k
Yup Ray...did you read the resolution note Don't use VDI lol
r
Yea I did man. That stinks
Move to Teams if you can.
k
I actually hadnt seen that article, made me chuckle. We may do that, or as mentioned earlier go local and published apps with netscaler VPN.
r
I also hate to see user move away from Citrix. Breaks my heart LOL
👍 1
Well VDI in this case
k
Yh, our solution is working fine, got a lot of good feedback as going from office to remote in 2 day period was no issue and system is running well. So need to look at other avenues and still keep with Citrix in some way.
c
Yeah, with VDI it’s real important to be plugged into other groups so stuff like this doesn’t get dropped in your lap. If VDI is a tactical solution you gotta be a part of the app review process which is always easier said than done
👍 5
r
What CTXMike said is 100% true
k
Agreed. Mike, this is why I was asking about the always on VPN solution in the Citrix channel the other day. Ill he honest, it's not solely due to this application, but it plays a part.
j
Really interesting discussion and so close to the bone as I’ve been having theses conversations every day since lockdown. We’ve got Skype on Citrix and it’s working really well but now management are in a panic every day and want Teams, Zoom, WebEx, etc. And I seem to constantly saying it’s not that simple to react that quickly on Citrix and have a stable system for 3000 users. Example, they want Teams ASAP and I have to explain we need to upgrade to 1912 1st from 7.15. And also upgrade all receivers to workspace app. That’s a huge amount of testing and all they know is you can install Teams on a laptop in 2mins, so why is it always different with Citrix. Complete lack of understanding and sometimes think it would be easier to just say to management, replace Citrix will laptops and let the madness begin......it’s exhausting.
👍 2
l
Its a draw back of what happening right now. Citrix is a strategic solution and is there for a reason. Remind them of that. ;-)
⤴️ 2
r
I am a die hard Citrix individual. I try to make everything work. No excusses 🙂 lol
💯 3
👍 1