This message was deleted.
# _general
s
This message was deleted.
k
I have no experience in sizing either AppAttach or AppLayering. I have some experience in sizing FSLogix, however whenever I forget the IOPS estimates, I always go to @Leee Jeffries article on his blog: https://www.leeejeffries.com/my-experiences-sizing-fslogix-profile-and-o365-containers/
..and if I remember correctly @Nick Panaccio has a great deal of experience with AppLayering, or is it @Nick Casagrande?
t
tnx Kasper, I'll check the blog of Lee jeffries
๐Ÿ‘ 1
k
Just remember that it is estimates, and there may be apps/settings/other on your environment which may demand more IOPS
j
For FSLogix containers, you need to understand your user utilization. How big is a profile - how big is Outlook cache, OneDrive cache, OneNote cache, Chrome cache, etc. etc. etc IME, I have found profiles generally get up to 40GB max in our environments, but we have allowed a max size of 100GB just in case
๐Ÿ‘ 2
l
Just chip in here if you're not sure, you've got all the right people ๐Ÿ˜‰
t
@Leee Jeffries reading : 12 iops for profile container, 44 iops for O365 container ... compared to Fslogix-reco talking about 2 iops ... big difference here
๐Ÿ‘ 1
so what about the storage itself : seems NAS is a bad choice and one should use Scale-Out-FileServer ?
@James Rankin today we use Ivanti Personalization ... but teams/onedrive etc won't be good, unless we'd use Ivanti vhdx mount (so choice to be made her Ivanti <-> FsLogix <-> ...)
j
FSLogix would be my choice straight off the bat, drop Personalization and just use UWM for Policy
โคด๏ธ 1
l
Its a large jump for the iops from what microsoft is recommending indeed. I dont know what they did for their testing but mine was done to ensure its a worst case scenario and then with standard deviation added to smooth any spikes. Have a read of the whitepaper, it runs through the scenario for the load testing.
๐Ÿ‘ 3
t
So Ivanti-VHDmount isn't a good option according to your experience ?
j
Might have improved since I last used it, but it was just leveraging PowerShell AFAICT
l
Nope, recently used it in the last few months, I found it quite unreliable.
Definitely go FSLogix. The two work together okay.
๐Ÿ‘ 1
โคด๏ธ 1
j
Yeah I've done multiple projects where Ivanti/AppSense was melded with something else. You could even use Ivanti to inject app-specific settings to FSLogix Containers for different OSes - so for instance a user could use Office 2016 on Server 2012 R2 and Server 2019 and you could make the Office experience roam smoothly despite using two different containers for the settings
๐Ÿ‘ 1
n
@Kasper Johansen: Yeah, probably me for App Layering. However, we don't use Elastic/User layers.
๐Ÿ‘ 1