I noticed the quote “Dataflow variables are specta...
# random
k
I noticed the quote “Dataflow variables are spectacularly expressive in concurrent programming” attributed to Bal, Steiner, and Tanenbaum on https://www.nextflow.io/docs/latest/. The link is to a 1989 paper titled "Programming languages for distributed computing systems" by those authors (https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/72551.72552), but I cannot find this quote anywhere in the paper. Can you help me find the source of this quote? Seems like the link should be the actual paper title?
p
ooh, this is a good one. That quote has been there for as long as I can remember but I don't think I've ever tried to chase down the source 😅
I just googled a bit and found a book that uses the quote, with the same citation you mention (which, appropriately, has the Sagrada Familia on the cover).
But I agree - I can't find the quote in the original source anywhere either.
The commit that added this to the Nextflow repo was 11 years ago: https://github.com/nextflow-io/nextflow/commit/33315072314a3575c315235f36c2b76497c6bcaf
Maybe @p can remember its origin?
k
Given that the paper predates Nextflow by something like 14 years and doesn't mention Nextflow or have that quote, I would think this should be removed.
p
Wait, you thought that the quote was about Nextflow? Ah I never looked at it that way
k
Well, it's at the top of the NF docs, so I did assume it in some way pertained to NF or at least "dataflow variables" and "concurrent programming," which appear to be related to NF?
p
Yeah, Nextflow uses that stuff
Nextflow is based on that concept, so it's related
Like a reference or quote in an academic paper
But honestly, I first saw it about 10 years ago when Nextflow was a small academic project coming out of a research lab and haven't really seen it with fresh eyes for a long time. So the framing of how it comes across could be entirely different now.