Hi, I'm doing a PR on bioconda, and they've added ...
# random
l
Hi, I'm doing a PR on bioconda, and they've added CodeRabbitAI. I have to admit that this is really usefull (as I'm not a C++ programmer and I've contribute only once). This could help to better standardize the module repository ? If we could do that we the new SequeraAI this would be even better 🎉 https://github.com/apps/coderabbitai
❤️ 2
s
interesting is coderabbit free ? or has open-source support ?
yes free for public repos
l
It seems free for open-source project. I have to admit that it worked well for the bioconda repository. This could help us to identify missing fields in the meta.yml and in the test cases 🙂
m
<!subteam^S016E36N7TQ>?
j
Trial it somewhere I guess
n
Yep we should make sure that it really does what we want in these cases
It could be a good start though, maybe put a disclaimer on every message that a human should always double check
r
What does it add over the existing lint functionality?
p
I tried one of these for MultiQC, not sure if it was this exact one. Found it extremely irritating and not helpful at all so switched it off again 😅
💯 1
But if it can be tuned or just works better with this particular repo then could be good..?
Any way to try before we buy turn it on?
m
btw. GH copilot has a similar feature now in preview: https://code.visualstudio.com/updates/v1_95#_copilot-code-reviews
🔍 1
l
It effectively seems that it proposes changes that aren't necessary. But you can add apparently learnings by giving him instructions.
a
I love the idea of renovate opening a PR for a tool upgrade, then an LLM fixing any (minor) issues but I don't know how well it works. I think it gave false confidence meaning this PR was merged prematurely: https://github.com/bioconda/bioconda-recipes/pull/51837
j
That's exactly my issue with all this automation stuff
💯 2
I think we are being too optismistc
AI giving suggestions is fine
But automerging version bumps sounds terrible to me too (unless it's a very small patch
x.x.1
relase)
☝️ 1
n
IMO a human should always do the final check but it could help speed up the review process by fixing common issues
👍 4
m
I want a verified by a human seal of approval
🚀 1
n
image.png
ai thumbsup 4
s

https://media.tenor.com/q8cL54vAoloAAAAM/security-on-duty.gif▾