Is there anyone here, maybe from the plant world, ...
# random
c
Is there anyone here, maybe from the plant world, who frequently does bulk segregant analysis? I have been for the last year or so, and I am wondering if it is worth proposing a nf-core workflow. There isn't a great end analysis tool -- that has been part of the project I've been on -- and there isn't much consensus in the literature that I'm familiar with around how to generate the counts, especially in haploid or ploidy > 2 organisms. If anyone does BSA, or has done BSA, I'd be curious to know your thoughts about the value of a workflow.
r
Not plants, but been mainly using this paper as guide https://github.com/emilyli0325/BSA_lifecycle
👀 1
c
For me, at least, this has been a problem -- there is a bug in haplotypecaller when setting ploidy to 1. I think this must affect the data in that paper, too, since they say: "We called variants for each parent using HaplotypeCaller and then merged using GenotypeGVCFs with default parameters except for sample ploidy 1" https://github.com/broadinstitute/gatk/issues/8943 Basically, in Haplotypecaller, when ploidy is set to 1, using intervals of different length causes DP to be reported inconsistently at sites where there is no alt call. It was only accurate, for me, when I set the interval to single base pair resolution. If the goal is confident genotypes, then the GATK folk claim this isn't really a problem. But, when you do care about the coverage over a given coordinate, it is of course. The advice of GATK, and what makes sense to me, is that the variantcaller/genotyper isn't really the right tool for this. Better to use that to generate the high confident variant sites and then use a pileup. Doing this is going to require that I re-do my current workflow, which is what has me wondering about the utility more generally. I'm curious if you have any thoughts
The QTL-seqr package is also the one that we're kicking around the idea of a version 2, by the way. I was also using it, reached out on github to ask about interest in a bioconductor implementation, and then found out that the original author and I are at the same university
👍 1
r
The organism I work on has haploid genome and so far we have been having good luck getting results that map to phenotype. Yeah it would be nice there is newer implementation of QTLSeqR