Ok, we all laughed about brobdingnagian rat genita...
# random
m
Ok, we all laughed about brobdingnagian rat genitals, but for now also a poor statistical choice perfectly suffices to generate a nightmare 😱. In the flagship paper of the All of Us Research Program published yesterday in Nature, they used UMAP to represent human genetic diversity and populations! That must be among the worst ideas ever in scientific publishing šŸ˜µā€šŸ’« - unless you want racists to have a field day. If not even the scientists understand the statistical methods they are using, how on earth can the general public in the Telegram groups, where those plots will inevitably end up being shared, be trusted to not be mislead by them? • Distances in 2D projections of t-SNE/UMAP plots are not directly interpretable! • Their loss functions are invariant with respect to rotations! Consequently this visual representation widely exaggerates the distinctiveness, a take-away that every racist will adore! Please share Understanding UMAP widely, so you and your colleagues know better when using UMAP in your manuscripts!
😨 5
j
Laugh in ancient DNA pop-gen, right @Thiseas C. Lamnidis šŸ˜
šŸ˜† 1
m
This has escaped me so far then 🫤. Fortunately, discrimination against Neanderthals is a problem of the past 🤪.
j
Oh you underestimate popgen
Huge amount of amateur (often racist) arm-chair 'interperetation' of ancient DNA pop-gen
this is fine fire 2
of e.g. Neolithic humans onwards
a
Or <insert your favorite take> on $population_x
šŸ‘ 1
😦 1