Theoretically if debit card gave the same % reward...
# credit
a
Theoretically if debit card gave the same % rewards like some credit cards do, would there be any benefit to using a credit card (besides perhaps some car rental places that only accept credit cards)
m
does it give only the % rewards or other credit card benefits like insurance, flight lounges, extended warranties, etc.
I’m actually creating a list now of all the benefits I get from my current credit cards. I’m not done but here is a partial list. “- Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance - Getting into your Rental Vehicle can be the start of a great vacation. When you use your Eligible Card to reserve and pay for the Entire Rental and decline the collision damage waiver (CDW) at the Rental Company counter, you can be covered for Damage to or Theft of a Rental Vehicle in a Covered Territory. Please read important exclusions and restrictions. Not all vehicle types or rentals are covered. Coverage is not available for vehicles rented in Australia, Italy, and New Zealand. This product provides secondary coverage and does not include liability coverage. - Global Assist® Hotline - Whenever you travel more than 100 miles from home, Global Assist® Hotline‡ is available for 24/7 emergency assistance and coordination services, including medical and legal referrals, emergency cash wires, and missing luggage assistance. Card Members are responsible for the costs charged by third–party service providers. Other terms and conditions apply. - $84 The Disney Bundle Credit - Get a $7 monthly statement credit after using your enrolled Blue Cash Preferred® Card to spend $12.99 or more each month on a subscription to The Disney Bundle. Valid only at Disneyplus.com, Hulu.com, or Plus.espn.com in the U.S.‡ - Return Protection - With Return Protection‡, you may return eligible purchases to American Express if the seller won’t take them back up to 90 days from the date of purchase. American Express may refund the full purchase price excluding shipping and handling, up to $300 per item, up to a maximum of $1,000 per calendar year per Card account, if you purchased it entirely with your eligible American Express® Card. Purchases must be made in the U.S. or its territories.” “- Once per calendar year, you can get $100 off of a $500+ hotel stay booked via Citi. - Reservations can be made in the primary cardmember’s or authorized users’ names. - If you cancel a booking made with $100 you can take advantage of it again in the same calendar year. - Extended warranty of 24 months on top of manufacturer’s warranty, for a total coverage period up to 7 years and up to $10,000. - Damage and theft protection for 90 days on items up to $10,000"
s
Isn't there more protection for fraudulent purchases
👆🏻 1
👆 4
f
Everything else being equal, the benefit of a cc vs a debit card (which is also its biggest pitfall) is that you don’t have to actually pay for whatever it is right now. Meaning, assuming you are a financially responsible person and you want to buy something but don’t have the cash now but you know that you will have it soon you can still buy the thing now.
🎯 1
m
I’m going to call that a negative instead of benefit. I would prefer a credit card with all the benefits I get that debited me immediately.
➕ 2
a
A key word in the question is "theoretically"... Merchants pay higher rates to process credit cards which pays for these benefits.
f
So if you move into a new house and want to buy a table and some chairs. The table costs $1,000 and the chairs cost $800 and all you have to spend right now is $800 but next payday you will have another $1,000 to spend. You could buy just the chairs now and wait two weeks to buy the table. Or you could use a cc and buy both now and be able to eat like a mentch.
m
Yeah I think that’s a negative, not a positive 🤷 YNAB fixes that by forcing you to pull from another category to fix your financial “lie” Living beyond your means is no benefit.
s
One of the biggest positives imo is fraud protection, like @strong-address-50370 mentioned. If the money actually comes out of your bank account, it's much harder to get it back than just calling them up and disputing the charge
🎯 1
f
What would you say in that situation if I know that next month I will not have to buy any other furnishings for the house so I am really just moving it from nexts month budget to this months?
m
That if you are living month to month like that you should not be owning credit cards
f
Sometimes after a big purchase like a house for example even a normally not paycheck to paycheck person could live like that for a few months
m
then i don’t think that person was ready to buy a house
Just my approach
a
Re: fraud charges. If you have only a debit card, claiming fraudulent charge will disable your card, leaving you with no way to make purchases. With a credit card, even if they disable your card, you still have your debit card. Plus setting up virtual card numbers to use online is real easy.
🎯 1
f
Or maybe on the contrary it gives someone who is otherwise living month to month and struggling a little bit more breathing room.
🎯 2
I don’t see an emoji for devil’s advocate anywhere 👺
m
if you find one on google i can upload it into the slack’s db of emojis lol
a
It's called riding the float, and people do it with checks too. (when checks used to take a couple of days to hit the bank).
also re: hotels and rental cars, even if they accept debit, they typically place a hold your card, which with a debit card ties up your actual cash
s
Yes it does enable someone to buy something this month when they'll only have the money next month... The better financial choice is to just wait until next month.
🎯 2
For me the biggest benefit of a cc is cash bacj. There are other good perks I rarely use. If all were removed (cash back and perks) I'd still use cc because of fraud prevention/response. I'd hesitate to give my debit card number to any only merchant, and even brick and mortar stores can have shady security practices. From what I understand, if someone fraudulently uses your debit card, you've lost the money. But a cc can refund it to you/cancel the charges.
a
There is some fraud protection with debit cards, it isn't as robust as with credit cards. Also with debit cards your liability depends on how quickly you report it
f
There's nothing negative about a zero cost way to borrow money if you're responsible. Someone earns enough and had a nice emergency fund that got wiped out due to a family emergency. The AC broke down a week before Tisha B'av. He'll have plenty to pay for it come the next paycheck. Should this person suffer in the sweltering heat for 2 weeks but ch'v not touch a credit card? Or should he charge the card, get some relief, and pay the card 2 weeks later with zero extra cost? Some "financial advice" is just stupid. Life is not a spreadsheet. There's room for that too, of course. But having a credit card with available credit is an exceptionally good thing for a responsible person.
💯 3
👍 6
s
Of course emergencies come up and things happen, life is very unpredictable. But that's not a לכתחילה way to use a credit card, which I think is the point of this discussion, or at least the point most people are making.
m
Ageed with @swift-vegetable-15776 I think @faint-rose-48029 missed the point we were making. We are taking about lehatchilah. Yes credit is a great backup plan, but buying furniture after buying a house is not unforseen.
I'm very pro credit card when used responsibly. The scenario painted that we are discussing is irresponsible.
s
@faint-rose-48029 Re-reading the original question now, it seems your message is coming to directly answer the question by saying it's an emergency option for when things have gotten very sticky very quickly. The rest of the discussion seems to have shifted a little bit from the original question, which is why I initially read your answer as a little off base and wanted to add my disclaimer.
🎯 1
m
Lol I guess we are all too new to slack 🤣 I definitely did not think he was answering the original question at all
s
Maybe we need intra-thread threads😂
f
Speaking of tangents, I was just thinking that I’ve met lots of people who sold insurance but I can’t remember ever meeting someone who worked for a cc card company
Or at least would admit to that
m
Interesting, I agree that's the case. (I know people who work at companies that also have credit cards but don't work on credit cards specifically)
f
Hmmm let’s start a conspiracy theory 😁
s
Maybe we can start #conspiracy, I'm sure we can find enough material to make it a very popular channel
m
It'll be the first conspiracy that even the Jews aren't behind apparently.
s
I know a few swes working at credit card companies
m
FinTech? or traditional?
s
I don't know what it's classified as... But I know someone at Amex and someone at Capital One
➕ 1
m
oh wow i guess that closes the conspiracy!
fun while it lasted
…unless you are part of it
👆 1
s
Otoh I know zero people working at health insurance companies in anything other than sales
c
xfiles
s
(moving this to random to not muddy this thread further!)
lolsob 1
b
credit card advantages - amex return protection and purchase protection. It's a huge advantage to me to buy something final sale and still get refunded if it doesnt fit, or to get refunded when a pair of shoes rip after 2 months. Extended warranty also but only used that once or twice
❤️ 1
s
@bright-restaurant-33087 wooooah it works on final sale too?
b
yes, I do it all the time. they sometimes ask for an itemized receipt and proof the store won't take it back - I once bought an in-store item that didn't have a breakdown and didn't get refunded, but otherwise have never had an issue. I take a picture of physical receipts if I think I might need to file a claim so that they shouldn't get lost
👍 1
a
debit card wont do that for you?
I've called my chase debit card and had them cancelt/refund certain things
b
not a dispute - return protection. I buy shoes online final sale, comes in perfectly good condition but doesn't fit. American express has insurance policy built in that will refund (merchant doesn't lose money)
a
and you dont have to return the shoes?
b
they t&c says they can ask you to return item to them at their expense but they never asked me. (never tried anything very expensive) https://www.dansdeals.com/credit-cards/just-how-amazing-are-amex-credit-card-protections/
a
thats pretty impressive, I guess amex is able to afford doing that from the billions they are taking from people who are poor at handling credit cards lol
b
forgot to mention, i think currently return protection only for the cards with annusal fee (like the 6% back grocery one many people here have), purchase protection might be on all
also, this gets me to use my amex almost everywhere even though it usually gives 1% back and there are other cards that might give more
a
how much is annual fee?
m
99 bucks. I didn't know about this final sale thing, nice! Thank you!
n
@bright-restaurant-33087 getting 2% cash back everywhere is probably worth more than the return protection. I used to use return protection when they had it on most of their cards, but they've dialed back.
Re fraud, my understanding is that legally, with a credit card, the burden of proof is on the cc company to prove that the charge is legitimate in order to charge you for it, whereas a debit card that's not the case.
To summarize: credit cards are a tool. In the right hands, tools are amazing and can provide tremendous benefits to the user. In the wrong hands, tools can be deadly.
💯 1
a
question is: is this tool more like a gun or a screwdriver? lol
m
On average it has to be a negative tool otherwise the credit card companies wouldn't be in business. The question is, can you be more responsible than half of America?
f
That's really not hard to do.
m
Agreed. That's why I use credit cards 😂
n
@mysterious-tomato-10057 they get a fee on each transaction, so it's not necessarily true, although we know it is 😂
😂 1
a
I agree with the dangers of credit cards being a source of unearned funding, but bidieved i want to point out that 0% apr cards (for a limited time) can be a better option than a personal loan or borrowing from friends, if you make minimum monthly payments, and are sure that you will repay before the interest hits, also better for your credit to do this on a business card (for example, the chase ink cards that are all the rage now for their 90k signup bonus have a 0% promotional apr for the first year)
n
Yes. I successfully took out a mortgage with about $30k out on a 0% apr business card, and the bank had no idea (I got a copy of what they pulled on me). Very stupid if you ask me, since I was personally responsible for that card. 🤷‍♂️
😬 1
m
Crazy! It's like how government departments don't communicate.
💯 1