I have a medical bill (close to $900) from Quest D...
# credit
n
I have a medical bill (close to $900) from Quest Diagnostics (lab) in collections. Long story, but basically Quest put a hold on it while I fought with insurance and forgot to mention the hold only lasts 45 days. Quest told me they can't deal with it anymore because it's in collections, although when I pressed the point, they were a little cagey, so I think it's not the whole truth. Waiting for a callback from a supervisor. I spoke to the collections agency (very carefully—they laid so many traps lol), and despite my best negotiating efforts, they said that Quest does not allow for any settlement options, only payment plans. Anyone have any advice for how to knock this bill down? It's truly disgusting, because had the insurance company covered, they would have paid out the negotiated rate of $220.89. But obviously I'm much wealthier than the insurance company, so I need to pay 4x that... 🙄
😬 1
w
If you won your fight with insurance, you should be able to get them to pay for at least some of it. We have had that happen before.
c
Did insurance cover?
n
Insurance refused to cover, even after many appeals and letters from the doctor, and pressure from HR. I'm working with HR on getting some reimbursement, but whatever that ends up being, it will be a check cut to me (I will be 1099ed and it's taxable income) and independent of my negotiations with Quest.
c
Ask a rav what you're allowed to do, but you could offer to pay the exact same amount insurance would pay (with in writing confirmation that it's full payment of the debt) and if they say no say great have a good day and wait until it get sold to the next debt collector who is willing to negotiate. But again, you'd need ask a rav if its allowed.
n
Ask a Rav if I can negotiate? Or refuse to pay? I'm not going to refuse because I don't want it to hit my credit report.
c
Refuse to pay. You could always refuse, wait a week and call back and pay it if they dont negotiate. The question would be whether such a tactic is allowed
👍 2
w
You've got 12 months to refuse before it affects your credit, and it disappears as soon as you do eventually pay it - https://investor.equifax.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/1222/equifax-experian-and-transunion-support-u-s-consumers
👍 1
a
Did Quest bill your insurance properly? Maybe check that with the doctor's office They most probably can recall it from collections, hence the cageyness.
n
@curved-toothbrush-84425 & @witty-engineer-80805 thanks! @acceptable-angle-23240 yes, they did. The insurance company is adamant that it's experimental and not medically necessary, despite multiple letters from the doctor to the contrary.
p
You can try setting up a really long payment plan. Eventually they usually cut a deal if you agree to pay the remainder off in one shot
g
If your in NY and you were not warned beforehand that insurance wasn’t going to cover it there is a form you fill out and ny will deal with it. Know people who did this multiple times and in every case either ny took care of it or the lab was to afraid and recalled and cancelled the bill
This also can be used as leverage against smaller labs who are scared of NYS getting involved, obviously quest is beyond that but this form saved my father 12.5k from a small lab when a test got sent out of network
n
@proud-waiter-61863 Thanks, I like that idea @gorgeous-author-37828 Is that from the federal Surprise Billing Act? Unfortunately, that went into effect in 2022, and this labwork was from 2021. Also, it wasn't OON, just considered experimental by the insurance company. I'm not sure that would be included under this Act.
g
It’s a New York thing, no relation to the federal thing. Even if you don’t think it qualifies it’s worth it to fill it out, it’s one of the few weapons we have against the labs and insurance companies
Also if you read the form that I linked above , you will see it applies to all surprise bills even from 2021
n
My insurance is from NY, but I live in NJ and the labwork was done in NJ. Also, the form looks like it's specifically for OON issues. Am I misunderstanding?
g
I don’t see what you have to lose
n
Fair enough. Thanks!
k
I’m wondering whether, if you settle it for less, it could end up on your credit report as having been “settled,” which is a negative mark. I’m not sure about this
I’ve seen this with credit cards that are reported as “settled for less than full amount” after a settlement is negotiated. That’s a negative mark. Because this is a medical debt, that may never happen, or maybe it would—I don’t know offhand all the nuanced rules and practices pertaining to medical debts.
n
I've seen reports of this. If I'm offered a settlement, I would require in writing that it will not appear in any form on my credit report before they see a dime.
g
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 Did you know before the procedure that insurance wouldn’t / might not cover this thing?
n
Nope, and unfortunately there doesn't seem to be any way to prevent this other than checking every test with insurance in advance. The doctor ordered about 15 tests. All were covered except one. In general, all labwork anyone in my family has done was covered.
k
You might want to contact a debt settlement / FDCPA attorney. You could try Simon Goldenberg
n
Worth it for this amount? He's gotta make money, and it's hard for me to justify paying him much...
m
My only experience here was when my insurance company originally said on of the lab tests wasn't medically necessary and I had to get the doctor to re-file it. I don't know what the long-term effect on your credit report would be for not paying. I would try yelling at the insurance company and the debt collectors that the doctor said it was medically necessary and if they have a problem they can talk with the doctor as he's the one making medical calls, not them. Either the insurance company should pay because it's medically necessary or the doctor should pay because he had you do something NOT medically necessary
Which is also why I don't think this is a halachic issue. It's not your bill to pay
m
It BLOWS my mind every time I hear stories that basically are summed up by insurance companies giving their medical opinions... Broken system.
w
Yes, just like the insurance companies pasken on what the best medication for you is.
🤮 1
However, in terms of the point that without insurance you get charged way more than with insurance, that one is the hospitals' fault that it's broken.
Well, it's shared blame at least.
c
@mysterious-tomato-10057 Idk. I see the point of it. Otherwise doctors could just order anything without thinking twice about it. Theres no reason for the insurance companies to give free reign to doctors who aren't the ones who need to pay out for the tests being done. I don't think its inherently wrong on either side. Its just the consequence of mismatched incentives.
w
The problem is balance of power. Insurance has absolute veto power to just say no to whatever they've decided, there's no third party board of appeals to determine medical neccesity.
👍 1
m
I don't know enough to know how to fix the current status of things. But I do know enough that whatever currently is happening is wrong. At the very least we need price transparency so I can compare hospitals before going.