Who can you recommend for selling my credit card p...
# credit
a
Who can you recommend for selling my credit card points? Looking to obtain the most value, in the least complicated way… (obviously 😉)
r
I used GetPayd before but it has been a few years…
m
I would recommending not selling credit card points as a long term plan as it is sub-optimal. But if you already have them and don’t want to travel…
r
In my case several years ago, the points were expiring and I had to pay tuition instead of travel
m
Yeah so beshas adchak it makes sense, its just very riksy
r
Risky in what terms?
m
r
Ah ok. In my case, they booked tickets from my United account directly using these points.
m
I think that carries similar risk, they have a lot of AI models running to try and detect it
r
They also taxable once you sell them
n
My brother, Hillel Davis 732-806-0616
@rich-insurance-32675 source, re taxable?
r
Like any other income, can't imagine why it would be different. The cost basis for the points was $0
m
don’t forget to give maiser on it
n
@rich-notebook-17814 That's logic, not a source lol There is at least one IRS case about this, and the IRS lost. It is not a $0 basis. It's viewed as a rebate on money spent iirc Not going to pasken, but I would certainly not assume it to be taxable.
r
Can you reference the irs case? That would be fascinating
n
@mysterious-tomato-10057 also not clear cut. If I buy a computer for $500 and get a $50 rebate check, do I give maaser on $50? I would assume no. Why is e.g. 2% cash back different?
m
so this is one of the topics i’m trying to get a rabbinic write up on 🙂 from all my digging so far, it seems you do give maiser on the cash value of points when you redeem them. But I will have a more interesting writeup on the topic soon
r
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 To clarify what I said, I wasn’t referring to the points themselves but to the money you get if you sell them. My CPA felt it was the same as any other income (in my case it was business income).
👍 1
m
I am also referring to the money you get, not the points themselves
n
@mysterious-tomato-10057 Okay, let's test the boundary 😁 Which of these cc rewards are maaserable? Instant discount on purchase (if that exists?) Cash back as statement credit Pay with points Cash back as ACH
r
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 not referring to cash you get from the CC company, but when you sell them to a third party
m
• no • only if you can have the option to cash out, if its only possible to do statement credit than no maiser • pay with points depends on if you can cash out • definitely masiserable
its all about “do i have the option to walk away with cash?”
n
@rich-insurance-32675 if the points are not taxable when granted, I'm not sure why they become taxable when sold. Perhaps you should press your accountant on this
@mysterious-tomato-10057 cash rebate check on product purchase?
m
Hm, i forget that one. I think yes maiser, but not sure.
n
So let's say on Black Friday store A sells a $1000 laptop for $400 and store B sells it for $1000 with a $600 mail-in rebate. In store A I pay $400 In store B I pay net $400 but owe $60 maaser?
r
There may be a distinction between rebates targeting specific purchases, and rebates targeting general spending. Love the conversation though
n
I hear that, but not sure why that should affect maaser. I'm very uncomfortable with the idea that a cash rebate is different than a statement credit if the source/purpose is the same. If I have my employer pay my cc bill, I imagine we would all agree that is maaserable (let me know if not) So the key is the source, not the method of payment. Either a source is maaserable or not. Thoughts?
m
I would only agree that the employer paying your credit card bill would be considered maiser is if it is optional. In other words, if you had the option to take the cash then yes. If it was mandatory then no. For example, because my health care is opt-in, I am choosing not to get paid so that cash value I do give maiser on.
Going back to my question of if I have the option to walk away with cash then yes I have to give maiser.
Which is why I think a rebate requires maiser but im still waiting to hear back from my maiser Rov.
n
Fascinating. I never heard this before, but despite my intuition objecting to this, it seems internally consistent. I want to mull this over. Thank you @mysterious-tomato-10057
👍 1
@rich-insurance-32675 saw a tax accountant in Shul today. He took the exact same view I did about the taxability of points and derivative cash. Don't rely on this as tax advice, but I'd definitely recommend asking your accountant about it.
m
An interesting nafkamina in airline points. If I have to spend them on travel and have no ability to cash out, then I don't give maiser. If I can cash out but I chose to buy airline tickets instead, then I do give maiser. Same purchase. Both airline miles. Only difference is the card giving me the option to walk away with the cash. Another similar nafkamina, my nana giving me cash for my daughters birthday party. If she tells me to buy xyz clothing with it, since I don't have the option to "cash out",I don't give maiser. But if stam I get cash for my daughters, then I do give maiser.
I don't think you would pay taxes on cash you receive through a process like selling airline miles because it's against the policy. Just like if I rent my basement out I don't pay taxes on the rental income bc I'm not zoned to rent my basement out. Right? Or maybe it's different bc one is a violation of a contract and the other is illegal?
n
I'm going to push the envelope here. What if you buy $100 of coins from the US Mint with a cc? Do you need to give maaser? If not, what makes it different than the rebate? (I know you still need to ask a shailoh 😄)
m
got the psak back that rebate is different and you don’t give maiser 🙂
its like a discount as opposed to the points/cash back which is like a gift
the concept of “if you can walk away with cash as an option you give maiser” doesn’t apply here because it is functionally a discount.
main difference here is WHO is doing it. the discount is from the seller, as opposed to credit card where the seller is not the person giving you the cash back.
👍 1