Hypothetical question, in the absence of any agree...
# random
n
Hypothetical question, in the absence of any agreement for this situation: Suppose there's a $100 loan with 10% interest compounded annually (we can do monthly, but the question remains the same). 6 months in, $100 is paid back, leaving a $5 interest balance. How should this $5 balance be treated? (could be multiple logical answers) Should it remain at $5 until the end of the year and only then start accruing interest, the way it would have if the loan hadn't been paid off? Now that I framed it that way, it seems that it's the obviously correct answer, but I'm curious if anyone has any other thoughts.
b
To me there is only one correct answer. Every discretely compounded interest (compounded per time period) has an equivalent continuous (every moment) rate (mathematically, the exponent of e). when debt is increased or decreased mid-period, interest should be charged at this rate.
I appreciate that was rather opaque, let me know if I can clarify.
6 months in, $100 is paid back, leaving a $5 interest balance.
I don't believe that is correct, it does not compound linearly. there will be less than $5 at 6 months, because part of the 10% accrued at 12 months is the interst on the interest.
e
I’m not following the question. A quick spreadsheet would help.
m
There isn't enough information in the original question. Was it a principal only payment or an interest payment? More importantly, it depends which type of loan this was structured at in the beginning. 1. Standard Interest Continuation: The $5 interest could continue to accrue interest at the agreed annual rate for the remainder of the year. This would be straightforward and keep calculations consistent with the original terms of compounding annually. 2. Adjustment to Principal Repayment: Some might argue that any payment over the principal amount should first go towards paying off accrued interest before reducing the principal. In this case, if $100 is treated as a repayment towards the principal, the remaining interest could either stop accruing further interest (if considered paid off) or continue accruing if it remains unpaid. 3. Ceasing Interest Accrual: Another viewpoint could be that since the principal is paid off early, no further interest should accrue, treating the early repayment as settling the account. This would be more debtor-friendly but less common without specific terms agreeing to this approach.
n
This question was sparked by someone talking to me about a large, complicated loan, with no such terms put into place, and payments made at random times, which got me thinking about how this could be handled
b
I don't know how these things work in practice, just thinking about how they should work theoretically.
I also didn't see your bio. I'm intimidated 😄
m
in a situation with no terms specified, i would think the 5$ of interest would continue accruing at 10% (this isn't how mortgages work, but it is how most person to person loans are structured if i understand the question correctly)
n
@bitter-soccer-1462 Don't be—I'm just a regular guy with a job lol
@mysterious-tomato-10057 But if the $100 hadn't been paid, it wouldn't have accrued interest during the second half of the year, since at the end of the year, we can all agree that the balance would have been $110
So why should paying the $100 cause the $5 to start accruing interest mid-year?
m
Accrued interest is not the same as compounded interest. I think @bitter-soccer-1462 is correct here. Even a "principal only payment" usually first goes for the accrued interest
m
I realize I was unclear. By continue accruing at 10%, i mean under the original terms of the loan. In other words, it would start accruing at the end of the year.
this is definitely not for the random channel. This is about finance!
n
@microscopic-psychiatrist-27869 I'm not sure I understand what you're saying
m
Meaning: 100 loan 6 months in pays 100. Total loan is 100 + 5 (accrued interest). Current balance is $5 from the original loan At year end, interest compounds on $5. Loan balance is $5 + $5*0.1 = $5.50
n
@mysterious-tomato-10057 So you're saying like what I wrote in the original q? The balance would be $5 until the end of the year and then start accruing interest in the following year? Ha, it didn't seem relevant to anyone's actual finances
m
Yes that is what I am thinking. I am assuming a strictly principal only payment though.
b
I think interest after 6 months is < $5. Anyone disagree?
n
@microscopic-psychiatrist-27869 But supposed I didn't pay the $100. Then I would owe $110 at year end, which means the $5 interest did not compound during the year (as it shouldn't). Why does paying the $100 cause the $5 interest to start compounding midyear?
b
(I'm working on getting the right math...)
n
@bitter-soccer-1462 I think it should be less with continuous compounding
👍 1
m
@nutritious-raincoat-28876, Nothing compounded during the year. The $5 left at the end is from the original loan and therefore accrued interest the entire year = 10% * $5
@nutritious-raincoat-28876, I think you are confusing Compounded Interest with Accrued Interest
n
Oh, you're saying $5 of the $100 payment paid off the accrued interest?
m
Exactly
n
Hmmm, interesting
m
I think we need to know if this is person to person or a mortgage type loan also (like no person to person loan i think would have frontloaded interest or take mid year payments as paying off accrued interest in my mind)
m
Mentschen macht heimish doesn’t mean they are doing the math correctly Also, person to person shouldn’t have interest 🙂
That being said, we’re back to that loan conversation from a few months ago comparing official loans with casual loans 🙂
What I explained is the “proper” way to calculate the loan and interest
m
Halachah definitely recognizes the fact that casual loans work a certain way, with simple compounded interest and no fancy math. If that is the way of the country, which it definitely is, to calculate simple interest with no continuous compounding calculus, then it should be considered a legitimate type of loan.
m
So even assuming that the ribbis issue is resolved, there still must be the idea of accrued interest. Otherwise, I can take out a loan for a year, pay it back after 364 days, and not pay any interest
m
I feel like that is the way people casually lend money but maybe i'm wrong on that...
yes it can be exploited, but its a good faith loan
b
The formula for compound interest is P(1+r)^n where P is the loan amount, r is the interest rate, and n is the period. so we have 100*(1.1^1) = 110 of debt after one year. After 6 months, the debt is 100*(1.1^0.5) ~ 104.88 debt, or 4.88 interest. paying off the interest leaves you with 4.88 debt, after 6 months that is 4.88*(1.1^0.5) ~ 5.12 debt. Now can I have my honarary degree?
Specific loans may have different terms, but that is the simple, straightforward calculation.
m
Your formula is incorrect
b
Where?
(If we take n to be 1)
m
My bad. I think your formula is correct, but I think the usage is not correct here
b
Tell me more?
m
It doesn’t work for fractional because you haven’t even reached the first application of interest (n)
b
I believe that is incorrect
Unless your loan specifically specifies that interest is only accrued once one period has elapsed, which seems a trange thing to do
m
If interest is not being capitalized, half a year of interest should be exactly half the interest rate
b
It's perfectly workable for fractional
m
🔥
m
Yeah but you are deciding that the interest will accrue at half a year. But it doesn’t. It accrues continuously as a percentage of the accrual period
💯 1
b
If interest is not being capitalized
Why would that be?
If it accrues cotinuously up to 10% at 1 year, it is ~ 4.88 at 6 months
accrues cotinuously = being capitalized, no?
🙅 1
m
I think it’s supposed to be prorated for half a year, not exponential
b
Why would that be?
m
Accrual means how much of the year was used. capitalized is at the end of the accrual period the interest is added to the principal and the interest is now charged on both the principal and capitalized interest
b
If I pay my debt and re-borrow every week, I would pay more in your world?
m
Not sure what you mean here
I’m 99% sure that this compounding formula requires (n) and (t) to be whole numbers
b
I understand. Maybe that's how real-world loans work, but it's mathemtically the less 'pashut' way
I'm 100% sur it doesn't
m
I disagree. If someone holds a loan for half a year, they pay half a year of interest
b
Lol, never ever thought I would be holding my own in a math argument
Only if the loan specifically specifies that interest is charged as a separate 'account' which is added to the principal at yearly intervals
Maybe that's what accrual means and that is minhag hamedinah. That doesn't mean my math isn't sound.
m
I’m correct here. There’s no such thing as partial year. If you are doing a partial year, such as 6 months, you instead divide the rate by half and use 6-month periods
b
There’s no such thing as partial year
I'm sure I'm experiencing one now?
m
Meaning, if you want to calculate the interest on half a year you use Interest rate * 6 months / 1 year = 5% per period and the period is a “1 6-month period” not “1/2 1-year period”
Which will give you $5 not $4.88
b
According to you, if I repay my 105 at 6 months and immediately re-borrow it, After the original year I pay 105+(105*0.1/2)=110.25
m
?
You’re paying $105 for the first 6 months and $105 for the 2nd 6 months
b
If I take the 6-month interest rate to be (1.1^0.5) ~ 4.88, 104.88*1.0488~110, which is consistent.
No, because I'm paying interest on 105 for the second six months
m
Why would you be paying interest on $105 for the second 6 months? Loan $100 6 months pay $105 = $100 + $5 accrued interest === balance = $0 Take out new loan $100 6 months later (1 year) pay $105 = $100 + $5 accrued interest === balance = $0 total interest paid = $10
b
if I repay my 105 at 6 months and immediately re-borrow it
m
Immediately reborrowing has no bearing. It’s a new loan with a new period which you’re paying back 6 months in
b
Because you decided to look at it that way. Both ways make sense, your way will lead to inconsistency if you do non-standard mid-period things, my way will not
i.e. you are required to insist that 'There’s no such thing as partial year'
m
Nah. I’m correct
b
Argument closed
I concede that may be the way real-world loans work, I have no knowledge. But it is certainly possible to compound to any interval you choose.
By raising to a real power, which is perfectly legitimate.
m
I think your use of the compound interest formula is incorrect. For a partial year, you don’t use a partial exponent. You instead prorate the interest rate and use a whole (partial) period
The problem with partial powers is that partial powers themselves are compounding because of the root / exponent
b
I've just demonstrated that it works (moulo rounding error.) Why do you think it is incorrect?
m
The problem with partial powers is that partial powers themselves are compounding because of the root / exponent
b
If I take the 6-month interest rate to be (1.1^0.5) ~ 4.88, 104.88*1.0488~110, which is consistent.
m
What you are basically saying is that if I borrow money for half a year, I pay less than half a year interest, which can’t be true
b
Why not? I admit it's counter-intuitive.
Part of the second half's interest is interest on the interest, so you pay more in the second half
And more in the last second than any other second
m
You are talking about capitalizing the interest. • Accrued interest is accrued continuously at the prorated amount. You are never charged interest on this accrued interest. Until it is capitalized at the end of the accrual period • Capitalized interest is when it “compounds” and you get charged interest on the interest as well
b
Ok
granted
but if I want capitalized interest, my use of the formula is correct
m
Yes but that’s not what we are talking about here. Annual capitalized interest is only capitalized at each accrual period, at the end of the year. Partial years are always uncapitalized and accrued at the prorated rate
b
I think we have failed to disagree
So your answer to @nutritious-raincoat-28876 ' question is $5, because interest stops accruing at 6 months.
👍 1
Actual halacha would depend on minhag hamedinah to choose between these two basis.
m
Actual halacha would depend on minhag hamedinah to choose between these two basis.
I can’t agree here because doing your partial way is not correct. Here’s a video if you want the correct breakdown:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&amp;v=cnxyn2JiUHo▾

b
Thanks for the discussion, I'm glad I had the opportunity to work the compound interest formula with a real example
So in response to the original question, there are two reasonable ways of looking at this question. The loan is defined as paying 10% interest after a year. • The interest accrues exponentially, and is charged to the same 'account' continuously, where it also continues to accrue interest. In this case, the interest after 6 months is approximately 4.88. If 100 is repaid, the 4.88 continues accruing interest at 10% and ends up at 5.12 at the end of the year. • The interest accrues linearly through the year, into a separate 'account' which is the cost of holding the money. At the year end, it is added to the capital and the accrual restarts. In this case, interest after 6 months is $5. if the capital is repaid, there is no longer a loan, and no longer a fee to pay, so this remains $5 until the end of the year.
The first grows slower up to a year, and faster thereafter. No, that isn't true. The first grows slower during the year, and coincides every year end.
m
Thanks for the discussion as well. Just to be clear, I don’t agree that there are 2 ways. Your method doesn’t use the compound interest function correctly. The reason is that the numerator in the exponent for a partial year is not the same as the full year. Therefore, it can’t be simplified together. This is the non-simplified interest calculation (the compound function is post-simplification) for example using 3.5 years:
Total = P * (1 + 0.1/1) * (1 + 0.1/1) * (1 + 0.1/1) * (1 + 0.1/2)
which simplifies to
Total = P * (1 + 0.1/1) ^ 3 * (1 + 0.1/2)
AND NOT
Total = P * (1 + 0.1/1) ^ 3.5
By the same definition, for 0.5 years:
Total = P * (1 + 0.1/2) = 105
n
Wow, I did not think this question would spark this level of engagement. I believe you two are disagreeing on a definition. @bitter-soccer-1462 is saying that the 10% is an APY, and there is an underlying (smaller) implicit APR that is continuously compounded and leads to a 10% APY. @microscopic-psychiatrist-27869 is saying that the 10% is an APR, so there can't be another underlying rate. Would you both agree to this framing?
p
I don't have time to read this thread. I'm going to vote the $5 doesn't start accruing interest until the year is up. And e doesn't come in unless it was explicitly set up that way.
m
I'm happy my answer is the same as @proud-waiter-61863 haha
p
I passed actuary exam FM about 10 years ago so that makes me an expert, at least it would if I remembered anything from those years.
FM deals with lots of time value of money problems
m
@microscopic-psychiatrist-27869 Is this different from what you arrived at?
p
Reading more bits of pieces of the thread.. I'm of the opinion that apy is a gimmick. Loans are defined based on an apr, and then marketing calculates the apy and advertises it.
n
@proud-waiter-61863 so you're agreeing with my initial hypothesis, right? Either one can be a gimmick, depending on how it's framed. Loans advertise the apr, because it's lower than the apy for monthly compounding, and savings accounts advertise the apy because it's higher
p
Yes I'm agreeing.
👍 1
Apr has a very simple definition. And Apy is something you can calculate based on an apr. Defining a loan based on an apy when It compounds more often then annually is a very complicated way of doing things
Now excuse me while I go read the fine print of my savings account agreement
n
For the layman, a 10% APR might make them think that if they borrow $100K at 10%, they will pay $10K/year in interest, but they'd be wrong, unless it compounds annually, which is unlikely
p
I didn't say easy to guess definition. But once you know the definition you can easily explain it. Apy is more complex.
n
Is it? You can define it as the percentage interest for a year 🤷‍♂️
p
From ally
. How We Calculate Your Interest We compound interest daily, using the Daily Balance Method to calculate the interest on your accounts. This method applies a daily periodic rate to the principal in the account each day. How does this work? First, we calculate a Daily Periodic Rate by dividing your interest rate by 365 (even in leap years). Then, at the end of each day, we add together the principal and the interest that has accrued to your account (including interest that hasn’t yet been posted) and multiply that total by the Daily Periodic Rate—the result of that calculation is the interest you earned for that day
It's calculated by dividing apr by 365. Not by working backwards from the advertised apy
Because that would be hard . Doable, but hard
And the last thing anyone wants is an agreement that requires too much math to interpret. Judges and juries aren't always great at math
n
Just reread what you said - my bad. You're talking about defining a loan, not the definition of apy/apr Agreed - it's simpler to define a loan based on APR
m
The original question was about 10% compounded annually, in which case the APR and APY are equivalent since there is only a single capitalization at the end of the year
👍 3
b
white flag
m
I love when frum finance board members like @microscopic-psychiatrist-27869 dive deep into a debate 👏