I think I've heard some people in this channel say...
# credit
b
I think I've heard some people in this channel say they have 20+ credit cards. Is there a reason to keep so many? Are they just cards with no annual fee so they help with credit score but aren't actually used?
c
If I open credit cards to get point bonuses I shut them down after 6 months. I don't like having too many open, plus you can't get the new bonuses in the future if you have had one open in 2-4 years usually, so closing them makes me eligible for them in the future.
b
Is it bad for credit score?
c
I don't think so. Maybe in the short term, but long term not really. My credit score is in the high 700s maybe even low 800s
b
Ok thanks
t
What! No you have to keep them open for at least a year or you will risk them clawing back the points.
@curved-toothbrush-84425 this isn’t all totally correct. You can’t get cards if you’ve ‘opened’ them in 2-4 years not if they are ‘open’. It’s from the open date.
@broad-australia-98095 the longer you can keep a card open the better because a big part of your credit score is based on the age of your accounts. So if you can keep no fee credit cards open that will help your credit score in the long run. Typically they will send a you notice that you need to use your card before they close it and then you can use it once a year to avoid it being shut down
c
I've never experienced any issues with getting anything clawed back
I believe it's usually both that you can't be a current card holder and can't have received the bonus within X years. Not sure what would happen if you close the card you had for 4 years and then opened a new one right after.
While you're credit score may take a small hit. I don't think one should ever make a decision based on what it will do to their credit score (unless maybe you're buying a house or car in the near future)
t
You can close a card and open it the next day if you haven’t opened it since the date. I’m just saying you’re more of a risk to close it under a year.
b
I definitely need to be somewhat cautious about credit since a house is somewhere on the horizon.
t
So you shouldn’t apply for any cards! What’s the time horizon you’re thinking?
n
Don't close cards - convert them to a different card if necessary. Saves the credit line. I have a lot of cards. Some active (different rewards programs, e.g. Amazon, groceries, utilities, etc.), some leftover from previous bonuses or rewards programs. No point in closing then and there's a benefit to having many open cards.
b
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 you're the one I was thinking of when I said 20+ cards lol. IIRC you were asking of a good way to keep track of them. How do you maintain all of them? I would probably just lose them once they don't fit in my wallet
@thousands-sunset-8939 about a 0-2 year range, depending on different factors
n
I was asking how to store them. Most of them just sit in a box. I have 4 in my wallet - primary, backup (non-amex) gas, and tzedaka. A few in Google wallet. The rest are either in online accounts or not used. Nothing to keep track of. They're all set to email me transactions and they autopay. Balances update to my Google sheet so I don't really have to login even to the active ones.
🆒 1
t
We talked about this when we first started frum finance @nutritious-raincoat-28876 lol. Yes if he can convert them BUT depending on what cards he wants to apply for he might want to close them. For example, if he opens an Amex gold he can convert it to an Amex BBP but he may want to get the BBP later for the sign up. For chase you can convert to the sapphire vanilla too.
👍 1
m
I tend to roll the credit limit into a card from the lender that I'm keeping long-term
k
Late to the party here This is a really simple tip but: One issue I’ve seen if people have too many cards open is they forget about some and then miss payments, hurting their credit score. Don’t rely only on AutoPay
👍 1