If my wife and I still owe money on our phones (ar...
# random
t
If my wife and I still owe money on our phones (around $700 total), is it worth it to switch to a cheaper phone plan? Mint has a BOGO right now, $75 for 3 months with 20GB data. Our phone bill is $161. But I can’t compute if it makes sense to spread the cash to pay off our phones now to save money on the bill. Help lol!
c
If you change the plan you need to pay the phones off immediately?
t
Yes that’s how they get you. It’s like no contract but you technically are leasing to buy the phones eventually or pay enough so you can upgrade.
c
What's the cost of the plans after 3 months?
t
It goes up to $105 for 3 months (per line). The BOGO is for $75 for 3 months
c
And now you pay 161/mo for both?
The breakeven point is the 7th month after which you save $91/mo. Seems well worth it to me, especially since you're lowering your debt burden at the same time. If you are able to pay it now it has a great ROI. Just make sure that they have decent service on your area.
t
Ok awesome! I’m just using their map online. Do you know if it’s accurate?
Looks good right?
c
Yeh but idk if the maps are açcurate. I would ask people in your area or search online to see if it has good service there.
Worst case you could always switch back
One thing I didn't calculate though. Does the 161 include payments for the phone?
t
Ok cool idk anyone who uses it
n
Checkout red pocket. They work with all the major carriers. I use their Verizon plan. I buy their annual plans for $180/year ($15/month) on eBay. 3gb data. They have higher data plans, which I have no use for (I'm almost always on wifi), for more, but I think still less than what you quoted after the bogo on mint. Been using them for years.
I've been happy with the moto lineup of phones. Usually buy a new one for $200-250 every 2 years around Black Friday.
t
Woah that’s crazy. We’d need more data. I can feel the creep of analysis paralysis though!
t
Cool thanks. This brings up an interesting aspect of FI and any expense vs experience conundrum. Do you go for the cheaper option that might have more work for you? Or do you pay a higher price for convenience? All these years I’ve stuck with AT&T because it was comfortable but seeing what I’m being charged now is ridiculous. Between Mint and Redpocket, RP is definitely cheaper but it requires more work for me to do, so Mint wins by default. Do you notice that with any other expense?
n
This is always true. You weigh pros and cons. How much savings vs how much extra hassle. How much can you afford on both sides of the equation. Careful to differentiate between one time hassles and ongoing hassles. One-time hassles tend to be much more worthwhile for ongoing expenses. But why does RP require more work than mint?
t
Oh well I thought I had to buy a plan through EBay.. but I see you can just sign up at their website. It seems like a pretty good deal actually
n
Used to be the annual plan was only available on eBay, and those were a little cheaper. Could be things changed 🤷‍♂️
t
Yeah looks like you can get on their website and it’s 10-40 a month still a steal
👍 1
k
One thing to remember about phone companies is: there’s the cost of the plan; the cost of the phones; the coverage; but there’s also the consideration of safety. T-Mobile in my experience has been prone to SIM swaps, which can result in you losing not only money but also your information and personal accounts.
I don’t know about Mint but it’s worth reading reviews online about it to see if it’s safe.
m
To answer the question about convenience at a higher price or cheaper things and the opinion from the FI community on the topic, this is where FI diverges from the old school FIRE culture which is mostly gone now. FI says to put your money where your values are. So if you can afford it and it frees up your time to do things that are more important, then do it. Read the book Die With Zero for more on the topic.
t
Great book. I’m all about what he writes there which is why budgeting and cutting out lifestyle things is challenging.