Can someone fact check my understanding of a mega ...
# random
g
Can someone fact check my understanding of a mega back door roth? • After maxing out to the irs limit on pre tax contributions (22,500) you can contribute more post tax money up to the federal limit of (66,000) into the 401k through the mega backdoor and convert that into roth money which would mean tax free growth
m
So I do the mega back door Roth, but I just contribute the additional money after the 22500 to a Roth 401k so there is no conversion necessary
But besides for the fact that your steps appear to have an additional conversion that mine doesn't have, it seems like we are saying the same thing.
g
Thanks, does the initial 22500 have to be pre tax?
Does that end up getting converted / put into a roth as well?
m
It can be pre or post. I do the whole thing post tax in a Roth 401k
e
Baruch - You are definitely converting but Amazon probably has it done automatically and immediately. Jack - that’s the gist of it but there are a couple of hurdles you still have to consider. The first $22,500 need not be pre-tax as long as your plan allows for Roth.
👆 2
m
Thank you Amazon for making my life easier 👍
r
Amazon does the conversion for you, if you dig into the transaction lists, you can see the money going back and forth, plus there is an extra tax form
m
@mysterious-tomato-10057 I'm curious what your reasoning is for contributing 100% to a Roth product and not utilizing a traditional 401k at all.
m
For me personally? Because i definitely don't recommend that for others
m
Ok, that's good enough.
I just see a pattern of many high earning people that put their money in Roth only and I can't wrap my head around it.
m
I mean I do it personally bc i'm betting my tax bracket will only increase, and my businesses/investments will continue to grow in generating income even after retirement age.
✅ 1
g
Don’t know how old all of you are, but On the topic I am willing to bet that eventually +/- 30 years the gov will end up double taxing roth 401ks and IRAs
they did a similar thing with social security, originally payments were not taxed until….
If you are young and have a long way to go till 65, that’s a long carrot to hope the gov doesn’t change the rules.
That’s personally why I blend both traditional and roth
m
I’m confused. If they double tax the IRA, doesn’t that just mean abolishing the IRA and making it a brokerage acccount?
g
Exactly
When the gov is desperate for money all things are on the table
m
new fear unlocked
g
🙂
m
any evidence that points to this ever being a possibility? or just your hunch?
g
They did a similar thing with Social security, not directly comparable but the same concept
Social security is a tax
they then tax you on the money you pull out
which was paid in as a tax
It used to not be like this IIUC
m
but that’s different than adding a tax to a specific TAX FREE vehicle
g
forsure, like I said not directly comparable
but something to keep in mind
If there is enough growth in roths that they do the math that it can fund program x if they tax withdrawals, it will definitely be on the table
vs Traditional where you are taking the money (tax benefit) and running
m
urgh you have me afraid now
g
Screenshot 2023-10-11 at 3.23.02 PM.png
Social security used to be tax free..
m
wow owow
e
Not double taxation - 1) you pull out a lot more than you paid in 2) at least 15% of benefits are non-taxable
Those politicians would be given a permanent vacation the following election cycle.
m
Agreed. So you agree that this isn't a valid fear?
g
Again I don’t think social security is “double taxation” technically, the point is that the gov will change the rules to suit itself later on and if you have 40 years till you can claim your roth money that’s a long carrot and I think a reasonable risk to think about.
e
I think a much more plausible and appropriate planning scenario would be one in which they simply raise tax rates, which would 1) put stress on the broader plan and 2) make the Roth even more attractive.
r
There was a proposal last year that didn’t pass that puts a maximum limit on how much money can be in a Roth IRA per individual (blame Peter Thiel). In other countries like Poland, the government just took the IRA money and setup social security instead.