Is selling credit card points complicated? I have ...
# credit
w
Is selling credit card points complicated? I have a card that has points and I want to close the card.
n
@mysterious-tomato-10057 is probably against it 😬 That said, the answer is no. Find an honest broker, he transfers the points and sends you the money. Done. If you're security conscious, change your password afterwards. If you're looking for someone to sell to, my brother buys. Happy to share. He's very ehrlich.
m
Hahaha I love that you know I would be against it.
e
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 what is this transfer, if not "selling points"?
s
On the few cards I have that give points, I can always redeem for cash (or a gift card). @witty-engineer-80805 do you have that option?
e
@witty-engineer-80805 why would you wanna close a card? If it is because of annual fee best would be to downgrade to a free card. Never ideal to close a card.
💯 1
m
plus1 to not closing cards and doing downgrades instead
c
I did it once. It was simple, but I was going to do it again and the rates are so poor I'm not even bothering. For Chase points they were offering 1.15c per point. If you travel you can get much better value redeeming them.
t
Yeah I would always use them over selling them. Even gift cards (gasp, worst redemption ever) make for a great present when you need to burn points.
n
@eager-keyboard-7093 the transfer is to someone else's miles account so that a ticket can be booked in their name. For gift cards, a point is generally 1 cent. Selling, depending on the points, rates can go up to around 1.4 cents. On 100k points, that $1000 GC vs $1400 cash. Unless you are booking business/first, or close to departure date, etc., I've found that there is more value in selling and paying for a ticket rather than booking with points. There is a psychological aspect of a "free" flight, but if someone can get past that (many people I know cannot), it's generally not worth it to book with points (unless one is against selling - valid, but even then, GC might be more valuable). Perhaps a specific flight might be cheaper with points, but generally some other equivalent flight will be cheaper. YMMV, literally
m
if you learn all the tricks for redeeming points, you can redeem for 2 cents or more.
👆 1
c
@mysterious-tomato-10057 Thats true, but it does require that you travel, and (from my understanding) generally that you have some flexibility on dates/location etc
m
True. I have seen hacks for 3 or 4 cents per point but it definitely requires flexibility.
I’ve started using it as a forcing function for me to take my family on vacations.
a
Not necessarily true about not closing cards. Sometimes having too much available credit is not good either. You should have a few staple (free) cards that stay around but other can likely be closed
Citi for example, doesn’t like a lot of unused credit
m
Unused credit cards and too much available credit are very different. I have 0 unused credit cards but a TON of available credit and no issues at all.
r
I’ve started using it as a forcing function for me to take my family on vacations.
if you spend more on the vacations because you "have the points anyways", then you're better off selling them even for a reduced value. Don't let the tail wag the cat
👆 1
m
Being intentional in using something as a forcing function is very different than blindly spending because you have the points anyway. I wouldn't go on vacation at all, and now I have something mechanistic that I can leverage to propel that desire forward. Even if I spend more because of it, I'm doing it with thought out planning that I want to go on vacations and choosing to leverage this mechanism to go me to do it.
So yes, I'll spend more because of it, since I haven't been able to get myself to plan a vacation even though I want to. But that is the exact outcome I am trying to achieve. Hence the language "forcing function"
👍 4
w
We are just not a travel family. 6 kids and one with severe special needs makes travelling, particularly by air, pretty stressful. @mysterious-tomato-10057 I'm ignorant - what's the rationale of being against selling points?
So let's say I never plan on using the travel points, and I have a card that gives airline mileage - if I downgrade it, it will still be for airline mileage, which is useless to me. Should I still downgrade it instead of closing it for the sake of my credit? It happens to be my oldest credit card.
t
Definitely better to keep your oldest card open forever. The average age of accounts is tremendously helped by your oldest card. If you need to downgrade because you’re paying a fee then go for it. But there is no reason to close your oldest card IMO
w
And the concerns raised above about unused cards? Do I need to find some token bill to recurringly pay with that?
c
This is just my personal opinion. But unless you are planning a large purchase in a month or two, I don't think its a good idea to make decisions based on your credit score. If it simplifies your life you can close the cards. It might affect your credit score by a little bit for a short period of time, but thats really about it. I close all secondary accounts I open just for the points because it just complicates my life (and adds some risk of fraud being done on a card I'm not checking in on every month) and my credit score is around 780.
🙌 2
t
That’s a great point @curved-toothbrush-84425. @witty-engineer-80805 there’s no real concern. Some people say that unused cards will get shut down by the bank. In my experience they usually give you a heads up before that happens and then you can go use it. I like the idea of simplicity though too as Yitzchak said.
e
Taking into account @curved-toothbrush-84425's point, I would suggest you check when your 'second' card was opened. If there's only a small gap between thenm than go for it and close it. Otherwise, it will be beneficial to downgrade the first card and keep it open, as credit history plays a big factor.
m
@witty-engineer-80805 if you are not a traveling family, you should have cash back cards instead of travel cards… I have decided to become a traveling family, so I am replacing my cash back cards with travel cards.
💯 2
w
Yeah, the travel card was because when I first got married and got my first all-grown-up credit card, my parents (who like to travel) told me to get an airline card. And then I never closed it. But I'm still curious what your opposition is to selling points, unless it's just that you don't think it's getting the most advantage out of it, in which case that doesn't apply in my case.
n
I assume it's because it's against the credit card companies' policies. @mysterious-tomato-10057 am I correct?
m
It’s against policy (ask a rov) and every time you do it you risk the company finding out and banning you as a customer (also forfeiting all your points)
c
We actually called up Chase and ask explicitly if we could sell the points and their response was "its your points to do with what you want". Not sure if they have permission to give it since its technically against the written ToS. But I wonder if they tend to turn a blind eye to it.
m
Sounds like a case of a poorly trained call center employee
😂 1
w
If it's not allowed why does it even work?
c
They log in to your account and purchase the tickets or whatever with it. There isn't really a way to stop that other than detecting it and shutting it down.
w
oh I thought there was some way to actually transfer the points.
c
Chase does have a way to do that. It exists because they allow sharing it with family members. However if a travel agent had a large number of people funneling points into an account I think they would catch on really fast.
w
so does that mean I can legitimately sell points to family members? 🤔
c
It would be easy to do, whether its technically a violation of the ToS would be hard to determine.