I keep wondering about the following. I grew up in...
# random
m
I keep wondering about the following. I grew up in a community where people had large families, the mothers didnt work and the fathers were on a spectrum from kollel/rebbes/teachers to successful businessmen/working in families businesses. I am super interested in peoples attitudes to personal finance, spending habits etc and discuss it with many people around me. I am not an expert in finance at all, but my nature is to save and i dont want to worry where my next meal is coming from so i work in a job that can support me. There are plenty of people I know who live well above their means, with their salaries pretty low, and i cant understand how it works and doesnt come crashing down one day. For a silly example, husband works a very basic job with low salary, wife doesnt work at all. They have fancy cars, eat takeout whenever etc etc and for simchas buy new expensive jewellery and sheitals. how? i get technically you can have a million credit cards and have loans, but if the income is always below the expenses, how do they do it? I see large families with the parents who were on v low salaries who’ve BH married off all 11 kids and are happy as can be. money is tight but they dont have debt collectors after them … how ?? like as someone put it to me once, why are we bothering being careful with money? for our own peace of mind? if we live like them we can have a such a good life…
w
For some of them the answer may be a line that I once heard from a Rov speaking to young prospective rabbonim: "When you and your shver decide to go into rabbonus..."
👍 1
😄 1
But I can't imagine that's all, or even most of them...
c
Some ways people make it: • The dollar value of government programs can be extremely high and take care of most expenses. So a family making 50-75k/yr with 10 kids might be receiving $100-125k in benefits (with no tax, which is equivalent to $150-175k of pretax income) and doesn't pay any tax on their income either. They're not living on $50-75k/yr, they're living on $200k+/yr. • There are many tzedakah and breaks that are given to families learning in kollel and/or with low incomes. This can include tuition breaks at school, discounts at certain stores for shoes and even sheitels, etc. • They may be splurging in some areas but not all. Its easy to think a family does all the things you think are excessive, but really each family is picking one or two excessive things. • They're managing for now, but long term they may need to rely on charity for simchas, or the support of their children when they get older. • Parental support
💯 4
As far as why work hard. Its a good question. I can only answer for myself and thats mostly because I believe being responsible with your money is one of the things necessary to living a moral life. Its certainly harder, but thats the price you pay for your values.
💯 3
s
Some people have yerusha money. Best is not to have that.
One perspective that doesn't answer why work hard, but does answer why not live it up: being used to a higher standard of living and not being able to achieve it makes for a very hard life. If you model a simpler way, and how to be happy with it, you're being mechanech your children well, and setting them up for a higher probability of happiness in gashmiyus.
💯 3
m
thanks all, stuff to think about..
m
I think this is a conversation that needs to be discussed a lot more at length. I think it hits the core of a lot of the problems we face as a community and that I am hoping to overcome with the frum.finance movement. It is a really tough discussion. When I am sitting with a family collecting 250k in government benefits with a household income of 40k, it makes me seriously wonder sometimes if I am doing the right thing by helping them pay off debt and increase their income. I know I am… but it’s hard…
🙌 1
@thankful-angle-58448 has discussed this also in other threads. Honestly I would love to turn this into a recurring topic somehow. I’m not sure the right mechanism, maybe podcast, I am not sure. But it needs to be discussed more because there is so much to unpack.
👍 2
b
Not quite on topic but mentioned in the original post - how do people get so many credit cards while spending to the limit? After a couple cards wouldn't you just not get approved for anymore cards? Or do people first open a bunch of cards and only then spend them to their limit?
m
it starts off with lots of balance transfers and applicatiosn and eventually they just can’t do it anymore and they get stopped because of the limits
👍 1
m
one of them told me they got lifetime ban from Amex but then opened more in wifes name, other people etc etc..
😬 2
n
Wow. I'm trying to imagine the world where someone banned from Amex comes to me asking to use my name and I say yes. My imagination is failing.
😅 1
b
I remember reading some “gelt” magazine from Ami or something. They were talking about people’s journeys out of credit card debt. One guy said he called one of these major cc companies and they agreed to a settlement where he pays like 40% of the debt and they called it even.
m
That is exactly what to do. I partner with an organization that does that for people. Basically the credit card company gets a tax deduction as a donation to help people get out of credit card debt.
m
i guess that answers my question. ive heard of that too. if someone has accrued 100k in debt and only needs to pay back 60k, thats 40k free cash .. and then why bother being fiscally responsible? this is the argument.. i honestly think its a different mindset that those of us who are into personal finance and being careful with money will not understand. when the other way works for someone, it can be a compelling argument ..
m
you can’t open credit cards again after that and your credit is WRECKED
you have to wait a while to be able to do anything after
and you end up paying thousands of dollars in fees and all your cards get closed
a
what i've seen people do is rack up the CC debt, at first playing the balance transfer game, then refinance their home, rinse and repeat...
n
How can you refinance if you have multiple maxed out CCs? The bank pulls your credit report. Or are they all business cards? Proverbial "you"
a
I don't know, so can only offer hypotheticals. Maybe by having other cards that are not maxed out? and otherwise being careful with credit (on time payments, maintaining history etc.)
m
the credit usually doesn’t go TOO low just for high credit utilization
n
There's also the income requirement
r
How do these people even have homes that they can refinance
m
they buy them before they go into credit card debt