ACH issue: I did a few small transactions with a ...
# random
a
ACH issue: I did a few small transactions with a buying group. 😬 Everything was delivered and the payment was sent yesterday. Problem was that I put the wrong ach account number (mixed up 2 digits). I fixed it right when I realized but I think the payment was already sent. My bank (Betterment) says there is nothing they can do to stop or hold an ACH deposit even though it has my name on it. The depositing merchant is very slow to respond. Any ideas on what I can do?
f
I believe it takes time until the payment bounces back
a
But you think it will eventually bounce back with the wrong name? The “wrong” account number could be a legitimate one
c
I'd assume they have a check digit so you cant just swap numbers accidentally and end up with a valid bank account #
👍 3
m
I don’t think you will have an issue here. Likelyhood of it succeeding is so low otherwise people would be doing this all day to steal money
a
How would they be able to steal like this?
I did read about a check sum in the number but I’m not sure if it’s just for routing
m
I could just request an ACH withdrawl from a random account and routing number until i get money.
a
But I assume deposit is much less strict than withdrawal
c
Separate question. What is a buying group?
a
It’s a reseller that you buy stuff for and they pay you back. People use it to get points and hit spending thresholds.
They are risky to use
c
Ah, I've heard of that. Sounds risky for sure
m
So as someone who has cleaned up the mess for multiple families from this, please stop ❤️
👍 1
Love you @acoustic-sunset-40897 but its not worth the risk
a
Lol I know that now 😂
f
Yep. I value my relationship with Amazon, other retailers, and my bank more than what I can get from these groups.
a
It’s less than 600$ in this payment. So not a major spend
Definitely understand the risks
Tried it out anyway
The truth is that this question doesn’t really have anything to do with a buying group. It can happen with my employer and ach as well
m
But you felt the need to confess, and we accept you 🙂
👍 1
🤗 1
a
You should charge for time in the booth
😂 1
m
We sentence you to 4 IRA contributions and 3 rebalances
😂 1
a
I accept the sentence with love
❤️ 1
But I am curious to see some of the specific examples of the mess you spoke of. Lost packages? The group owner refusing to pay?
There can be many, I’m just curious what you saw
m
all of a sudden racking up a bill then refusing to pay
👍 1
after years of it being fine
👍 1
n
Also, there are easier ways to rack up points. (Over)paying federal taxes is a great one. Fee is 1.85%, which is rock bottom. I just paid ballpark $13k when I owed $3k. Got lots of bonus points, and got the refund about 2 weeks later, just in time to stuff an IRA before April 18. Icing on the cake is 0% apr on purchases for a year (maybe 15 months?). 0 risk (that I can see).
Disclaimer to the above: do not borrow on a 0% apr cc unless you know exactly how you will pay it back
a
Wait what? You can just pay extra federal taxes and they send it right back? Or you refile?
c
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 You have cards that pay over 1.85% with points? How do you make money from it?
@acoustic-sunset-40897 You can pay estimated taxes any time throughout the year, so if you overpay near the end of the year you would get the balance back when you file shortly after.
a
How long does it take to get the money back from the IRS though?
n
@curved-toothbrush-84425 my regular spend card is 2% cash back (there are several such cards out there). But that's not worth the hassle for 0.15%. I did that to meet spending thresholds to get a bonus. Spent $18k in 3 months to get 270k+ UR points. Paid some tuition (absorbing the fee), prepaid $2k of utilities, and finished up with overpaying taxes.
@acoustic-sunset-40897 once you file, you get the refund in about 2 weeks. If you make an overpayment on 2023 taxes now, you will not see that money until you file 2023. Of course, if you're self-employed, you can pay the correct estimate that you would be paying anyway.
m
@nutritious-raincoat-28876 This is an awesome hack
Are there any limitations here?
n
With this spending method? 2 payments per person, per payment processor, per payment type (each quarterly and the filing payment). Spouse on married filing jointly can sometimes require a call to the IRS to link up. Just did it for the first time. My credit limit was low, so I ended up doing 2 payments with one processor and 2 with another at 1.87%. Showed up in my IRS account within a day or two and there were no issues getting the refund.
m
but like, lets say I have a 100-200k credit limit. Can I just go crazy here?
c
Maybe the credit card company would shut you down?
m
for using my card?? I can’t imagine that
they want those processing fees
c
Does the IRS pay the same processing fee as regular merchants?
🤷‍♂️ 1
Sounds like something where you can make some money by being early, but after a year or two the fee for cc payments will change lol
Theres also the risk that the IRS takes longer than expected to get you your refund.
m
government being late? never
😂 1
n
These payment processors are separate from the IRS. Pretty sure the IRS just gets the net from the processor. I did remember seeing a dollar limit, but it was pretty high. I would be afraid to do an amount I couldn't cover without the refund in case the IRS decides to sit on it. That would also mean that they pay interest (past 45 days I believe), so you wouldn't really lose out.
m
moneyparrot
yes the parrot is holding money
n
c
Keep in mind that even for $100k. The 0.15% spread would mean you net a whopping total of $150 for your troubles.
If you sell the points, you might be able to increase that by 2-3x, but thats about it. If you redeem them properly, you might get $1k or so of value.
m
I wonder what category of purchase this is. If its internet, you could get like 3-5%
c
Only if its the bonus category at the end of the year
m
idk what you mean by that. I have a card that gives a high percentage for specific categories
c
all year?
m
yeah
if you are preferred rewards at BOA, the customized cash rewards card gives you 5.25% on a category of your choice
c
Is there a cap?
m
2500 a month 😞
c
2500 of spend or 2500 of rewards?
m
spend
still 30k over the year per card
open up a few of them prepay taxes and BOOM instant millionare
😂 1
c
You would need to open 12,699 cards to get $1M in gross rewards using this strategy.
lolsob 2
m
you forgot maiser
c
fixed it
😂 1
m
I promise to share the riches with all of you
BL”N
a
While we're on the topic, are there any ways to send money to a friend using a credit card that won't code as a Cash Advance? I'm fine with the 3% fee. CashApp + Chase CC Coded for me as cash advance
m
$3 fee
a
But I cant turn amex gc into cash
m
its as good as cash
a
Not to pay off a CC bill
c
sketchy
n
What about PayPal?
👍 1
w
While we're on the topic of ways to spend money you are required to spend, does anyone have any good hacks for gift card programs that many frum schools have (for example, I'm required to spend 7.5k in gift cards purchased from my daughter's school or pay some % of penalty on the remainder.)
a
I've done the money order game in the past. Is that what you are referring to? https://frumfinance.slack.com/archives/C04FDN85LE4/p1682534494561339?thread_ts=1682520493.076339&cid=C04FDN85LE4
c
I'm required to spend 7.5k in gift cards purchased from my daughter's school or pay some % of penalty on the remainder.
What does this mean?
m
@curved-toothbrush-84425 I was also so confused and had to DM him a hundred questions to understand. It sounds like a weird thing where non profits funnel expenses through gift cards that they get at a discount to lower costs.
c
🤯
m
like, “hey instead of paying us 10k in tuition, buy 9500$ in giftcards at the local kosher super market”
That is what it sounds like to me lol
n
More like buy $10k of gift cards to the local supermarket where you will shop anyways and we make $500 commission, or pay us $500.
m
Is it optional or mandatory? What if you don't spend that much at the local supermarket? Sorry I guess I still don't really get it.
n
Every school has its own policies 🤷‍♂️
m
Either way, obviously it's not money you would have definitely spent anyway at the location, because then there would be no incentive to be selling the gift cards at a lower rate
n
I think the store's motivation is competition and tzedaka. There are multiple supermarkets, so this gets people to spend in theirs.
w
They actually have tons of "normal" stores in the list of giftcards. Including Amazon and Starbucks, for example. But also including the kosher supermarket. And you can easily fulfill your quota with money you would have spent anyways.
m
Starbucks gift cards have enough money in them that they are essentially operating a bank at this point.
a
Update: The payment did indeed bounce/returned. So that’s good.
👏 1
r
Anywhere you cam still buy money orders with visa/Mastercard gift card?