First off, congrats on having these opportunities! Sounds like people recognize the value you bring.
One thing that helped me on my career journey is making a chart where each factor is weighted: work-life balance, benefits, salary, type of work, etc.
Then when I was choosing between offers, I would look at how ALL of the factors added up (depending on how you weighed them), instead of the single salary number.
For my current role, I actually turned down a competing offer for $10k more because the work-life balance and title meant more to me in the long-term. I think salary will be a bigger factor in the next role I choose, but for now I'm really happy with my decision.
So, TLDR, take some time to write out non-salary factors and see how those stack up