https://chillsubs.com logo
As an author, I want form rejections to be polite ...
# editors-chat
d
As an author, I want form rejections to be polite and concise. These goals conflict, of course; a simple “no” would be very rude. I appreciate being thanked for sending work. I tolerate uninformative but mollifying hedges like “we publish very little of what we receive” (put numbers on it!) and “after careful consideration” (maybe, maybe not) and “we receive a lot of great work” (surely stretching the definition of “great” here) and “not quite a fit” (don’t @ me; I didn’t write Variant’s form). I find “best of luck” annoying even though no sensible person would read it as “you’d be lucky to get these published.” I’m seriously irritated by self-promotion. The other big no-no in my book is sending too many warm rejections. I don’t feel comfy carpet-bombing open calls, and this signal, used appropriately, helps me prioritize.