Hey.
You don't need to use Trim Settings. You certainly can, but that mechanism is primarily designed for complex setups and large projects where there might be multiple team members. In such cases, the team leader assigns Settings for each trim, and others simply use them.
In your case, set the Fit Axis property to Min. This way, the operator will find the shortest island side and match the scale along it. Specifically for your case, this will do the trick. However, if your island is rotated vertically, the result will be different because the shortest side will be the width rather than the height. For such cases, try using the Match Rotation option.