Sounds similar. We found the issue to our problems; it seems the old CA server did not have a proper CDP/CRL configuration therefore all the certificates’ issues by it had the CRL pointing to the LDAP location of that server. When that server got decommissioned it caused CRL smart card failures because it couldn’t find the LDAP location of the old server. We end up removing/rea-adding the Citrix Smart Card certificate template, forcing all Citrix users to get the new smart card certificate from the template, renewing the Kerberos Authentication certificate on all our Domain Controllers (so it can have the correct CRL) and rebooting all Citrix Servers and Domain Controllers. This finally corrected the issue.