This message was deleted.
# citrix-vad
s
This message was deleted.
p
Easy enough to spot if the image is bad with a pilot release. Personally I like the least amount of images. Sometimes you are forced into splitting them though for compliance reasons.
j
One image with a four-tiered rolling test release cadence
👍 1
m
Trying to go with 1 monolithic image here and app masking. App Layering has always been too much effort for me and had too many things go wrong.
👍 1
o
One image is the way to go if possible. The last project @Jonathan Pitre / I did last year, we had to use two due to a requirement for office 32 bit, but, we probably could have done with just one image if we made more time. FSL + App masking turned out to be a perfect replacement for App Layering ; which was originally scoped for the project. As Mike said, APPL is a lot of work for little reward
j
FSL + App Masking + AppVEntix FTW
j
I agree but I would avoid AppV at all cost, only use when absolutely required
t
I was attempting this but will probably go with two images as I can’t get AppMasking to work consistently. Plus with two images I can use different virtual hardware specs.
j
AppVEntiX is quality for us, no infra required, it just updates everything straight into the workers on-the-fly. FSLogix controls the access
👍 1
c
Well thanks, I think I will do the one.
d
@Mike Streetz (O_P) Friends don't let friends use Citrix App Layering 😂
😂 3
p
What’s with all the hate on App Layering? Serious question. It’s been a game changer for us.
m
When it goes wrong it takes forever to pin down where it went wrong and why
j
Takes too long to configure for me. There are much slicker ways to deploy apps quickly. And as said before troubleshooting can be difficult. YMMV
j
Similar results can be achieved with FSLogix App Masking with less complexity for the admins and less single point of faillure
👍 1
+Management Console with SIlverlight, complexity sealing the image, shitty sealing scripts provided by default, when the DHCP range is full you get a timeout error instead of getting a DHCP one...Adding a disk for MCS/PVS Cache is PITA etc.
p
App masking implies the apps are in the image. Curious on how those images are being built and deployed for non persistent systems. We are leveraging FSLogix to mask some apps which helps with our gold image count, but we are still building those images with AL. I let MCS / PVS worry about adding the Cache disk. I should probably open another thread rather than contaminate this one further.
j
According to AppLayering doc you need to add it in your Platform Layer, shutdown, remove it and then finalize....good luck explaining this to the customer
p
I’ve only ever seen that noted in CTX225952, and then it’s an “If you need to” statement.
j
See CTX232126
p
Thats also a CTX full of if’s and maybes.. IDK. Maybe it’s because we use Citrix Hypervisor & the “Virtual Desktop Setup Wizard” in PVS, but we just build the platform image without attaching any other disk and PVS / MCS creates and mounts the cache disk on build of the VM.
j
Good to know, I will test without it then, thanks for your input
t
We have been using App Layering since Citrix bought it and it’s been pretty solid for us. At the beginning the platform layer used to implode after a few versions, but once that was fixed it’s given us a lot of flexibility. We get the odd problem but it’s normally fixed by changing the layer priority. Saying that my big project this year is to try and find one automated process for building our apps and images across all our platforms.
j
do you think they'll get that console switched to HTML5 before 2030?
p
lol. Good news is it works in Edge IE compatibility mode.
😯 2
j
really silverlight works with Edge compatibility mode ? I'll have to try that
p
I was surprised too.
t
Ha ha! I use IE tabs plugin in Chrome for silverlight. Citrix lack of improvements to their numerous consoles is annoying.