This message was deleted.
# citrix-vad
s
This message was deleted.
k
@dready ⤴️
d
@Kasper Johansen IGEL can do it, works pretty well. See https://virtualbrat.com/2020/09/18/microsoft-teams-optimization-in-igel-os-new-release/ @Rody Kossen might have teated it with Stratodesk
👍 1
c
I am using wyse and works well. But have not scaled yet still testing.
k
@Cory Zaner which model?
c
5070
k
ThinOS?
c
Make sure you get the thin os9 it have the latest workspace
Yes
k
OK. A customer with 5070 experience issue with Teams Meetings lock up, when you hang up, session is then stuck for a couple of minutes
What version?
k
Customer has that CWA installed
The one you link to
c
I am on prem. I can test Citrix cloud when I get back.
k
Thanks
m
I had that, as soon as I shared my screen the audio quality dipped, but it came back
not on wyse
our wyse won’t do optimizations, too old
c
Actually now that I think about it happens to me too.
😕 1
k
So, it's safe to assume some kind of bug in the OS?
m
I think it’s teams handling the sudden change in bandwidth required
it takes it from the audio stream temporarily
although in your case it doesn’t sound like it gives it back
k
My customer was monitoring the CPU usage of the TC, and noticed that when the audio was getting choppy, the CPU usage was above 60%
Considering how the optimization works, that doesn't sound like an issue with Teams
but then again, it's linux you never know
Is it safe to conclude that, right now it's only with IGEL that the Teams optimization works reliably?
c
haha you Said "Teams Optimization" and reliability in the same sentence.
😂 1
k
The customer in question here and I just had a meeting. They are not happy, which is understandable as they are mainly on thin clients, not many laptops around
c
I pinged our SE, will let you know
k
I have pinged Fernando Klurfan, the PM on Teams HDX Optimization 🙂
Let's see who answers first 😄
c
thats better then me
k
Yeah, but SEs usually have better time for these kinds of things
c
i was told others have this issue to open a ticket
@Kasper Johansen support said people report same issue.
k
Thanks @Cory Zaner
My customer has an open support ticket with Dell and Citrix is also involved, so let's see what happens
OK. Dell/WYSE has confirmed there is a known issue with Teams HDX Optimization with their Dell/WYSE 5070 (with the J5005 CPU) which results in a high CPU load and poor/choppy audio and degraded video performance. My customer just received confirmation today. I have notified Citrix of the issue.
Happy days...
Customer is about to replace 200+ thin clients with the 5070, he is not a happy camper at the moment
r
Ouch.. that's one of the "issues" of offloading, your device needs to be able to handle it. The J5005 doesn't seem to be that old, strange that it can't handle it.
k
It should be able to handle it according to Citrix
r
Can't you test with a IGEL or Stratodesk USB stick? To see if it is the hardware?
If that works, Dell should fix it 😉
k
Hmm..good point. I actually have a IGEL USB stick available
Time to do some testing
r
Try to pick the latest IGEL build with the CWA 2009 for Linux, otherwise EDT performance is poor
k
Will look into it, Thanks 🙂
c
@Kasper Johansen disable EDT, I have bad performance with EDT. The latency was 40-70ms with edt and disabled edt it went to 1ms.
k
In general of with this case?
c
In general
With edt I had 70ms
This didn’t have an impact on the teams issue, but does help with overall performance
r
@Cory Zaner Which Workspace App version do you use? Linux based I assume?
c
Yea, 2006.1130. Latest firmware too
r
There is a known issue with EDT an CWA for Linux which is fixed in CWA for Linux 2009: https://docs.citrix.com/en-us/citrix-workspace-app-for-linux/whats-new.html#fixed-issues In a session running on UDP connections, the performance might be slow. [RFLNX-5135] If possible, update to CWA 2009
c
Haha this is a Dell wyse device I am at there mercy.
r
🙄
k
Yeah, Dell isn't that fast
They are still at CWA 2006
c
We selected them because of the hardware and the cloud manager. I don’t need anymore stuff Onprem to manage.
m
I’m not a fan of them at all, the cloud manager is completely unintuitive and the hardware doesn’t seem any better than anyone else. Wyse support is amazingly bad too, not sure why anyone would pick them other than for technical debt reasons.
c
I really wanted igel but could never really get it to work right. We didn’t like the hardware and the thought of reimagining thin clients was not appealing. Dell is not the best but works for us. We only use them for Citrix. Version 9 is a lot better and they have 9.1 coming.
k
Dell has told the customer that there is a know bug with CWA 2006 in ThinOS, which affect Teams HDX Optimization. It's fixes in CWA 2009, but that version has some other issue with ThinOS, so they are currently not recommending going to CWA 2009 in ThinOS
Happy Days!
c
@Kasper Johansen what’s your ticket number if you don’t mind? I will ref your on mine. Also you make any progress!
k
SR: 1037666629
It might be closed though, however I hope they have some kind of history
c
Did they fix it for you?
k
According to the customer it's not fixed yet
c
They told me Nov 9th is the release for the share
@Kasper Johansen the firmware is out for the fix for dell
k
Nice
Thanks for the info I'll notify my customer
c
I tested and it worked
k
@Cory Zaner are you testing with Teams Offloading? What models are you testing?
My customer has concluded that the 3040 model is not fast enough to do offloading
The 5070 is much better
c
5070, I dot have a 3040, I think in the release notes it says that the 3040 is not supported
j
3040 are not supported for Teams by neither Citrix or Wyse btw
• Minimum 1.8 GHz dual-core CPU that can support 720p HD resolution during a peer-to-peer video conference call. https://docs.citrix.com/en-us/citrix-virtual-apps-desktops/multimedia/opt-ms-teams.html#system-requirements • *Microsoft Teams video call and share screen*Video call and share screen features are not supported on Wyse 3040 Thin Clients. https://www.dell.com/support/manuals/en-ca/wyse-3040-thin-client/thinos9.0_rn/new-and-enhanced-features?guid=guid-63587b8c-42f5-448e-9489-dcaecebde4cd&lang=en-us
👍 1
k
@Jonathan Pitre I know, but you can't blame my customer for trying. They have at least 250+ 3040 units running