Following up on my post from last month (
https://starrocks.slack.com/archives/C02FAD0JSSD/p1791279083204069) about how external PRs get reviewed and merged, which didn't get a reply.
In the meantime, open PRs have gone from 900+ to 1,124. The PRs we flagged had another AI review and have had no activity since. As far as I can tell, the AI review is where external contributions stop: contributors address the feedback, ask for review, ask here, and then hear nothing for months.
I looked into why, and it seems to be structural. CODEOWNERS auto-requests were disabled in #74641, and external contributors can't request reviewers or add labels, so nobody gets notified when a PR is ready. CONTRIBUTING.md just says maintainers will review "as soon as possible", and the review and contacts sections still say TBC. The old forum link on GitHub Discussions no longer resolves either, so this channel is the only place left to ask.
These are usually people fixing problems they're hitting in production. When that work is ignored, contributing to StarRocks feels like contributing to a closed project, and people will stop bothering.
I've raised an issue proposing the missing process be documented, and offered to draft the changes:
github.com/StarRocks/starrocks/issues/82526
Could someone from the maintainer team please pick it up and tell us who owns triage of external PRs? And if you're an external contributor with stalled PRs, please add your experience to the issue.