Hi Everyone, this might be a silly question, but w...
# help
j
Hi Everyone, this might be a silly question, but was just wondering if anyone out there has developed a complete SaaS solution using SST? Are there any boilerplates or templates available? Ideally the auth and payment are already pre-baked, and I'd be able to focus on the app functionality.
t
we're progessing in this direction but we're not there yet
We're still on the basic stuff but we will get into specific features like that
j
Thanks for the info, this is great so far!
d
Just curious. Why are we rolling our own auth instead of using Amplify
t
Amplify works but I'm not a fan of it
it breaks as soon as you have custom auth flows
d
For sure. I’d just like to understand why, the tradeoffs. Gotcha I see.
Auth seems like true worst case for “undifferentiated heavy lifting”
t
And when I looked at the internals I didn't get the feeling of "the people working on this are smarter than me" which is my criteria for most of the things we've selected
Yeah auth is tricky. It's 100% undifferentiated if implemented correctly. But no service really has it implemented correctly (imo)
We're figuring out what we're doing for auth still, likely gonna not be in there for the first release but we'll document how to use various setups
d
My only experience with auth really is Amplify and Amplify-UI-react
I fired up the ideal stack this morning and was surprised to find it password protected
t
Yeah that's in there for now but we're likely going to remove it
d
If i have issues/comments on the ideal stack. create an issue in github'?
j
My advice on payments is don't even try to do it yourself. Use something like Stripe and you don't have to worry about compliance and any security issues.
t
yep would just be a thought through integration with stripe
j
Btw, on the auth-side, I agree with you on that Cognito sucks. Do you have any other recommendations currently? I trialled Auth0 recently and it just seems marginally better but not enough for us to move across.
t
I'm fairly confused here as well I have the perfect auth flow implemented for a b2b service but it's all hand rolled. I have not been able to recreate with any other auth provider and I need to sit down and find clarity on what parts of it makes sense to outsource
j
Yea fair, Well, maybe you guys could launch another company/project haha. I definitely am interested!