Is there a better option from the <Permit.io> team...
# opal
e
Is there a better option from the Permit.io team on using OPA vs Cedar?
a
Hi @E2, I'm an AI assistant for Permit.io. I'll analyze available sources and get back to you shortly.
Permit.io supports both OPA and Cedar as policy engines, and the choice depends on your specific use case rather than one being universally "better." (1) (2) (3) *OPA (Open Policy Agent) * is a multipurpose policy engine that uses the Rego language. It's extremely flexible and can handle complex decisions across your entire stack. (2) (3) OPA excels at fine-grained permissions supporting RBAC, ABAC, and ReBAC (with certain adjustments) , and offers high performance with in-memory caching. (2) However, Rego has a significant learning curve as it's a logical programming language. ​*Cedar*​ is specifically tailored for application-level authorization and is designed to be highly readable. (2) (3) It emphasizes safety by default and provides structured, verification-guided development. (2) Cedar supports RBAC, ABAC, and ReBAC, and is particularly well-suited for fast ABAC-based decisions with built-in auditing and static analysis. (3) The trade-off is that Cedar currently has a smaller ecosystem and less established community compared to OPA. (2) Permit.io's platform works with both engines, abstracting their complexities through APIs, SDKs, and a no-code UI. (1) The platform also uses OPAL (Open Policy Administration Layer) to keep both OPA and Cedar updated in real-time with policy and data changes. (3) The decision comes down to your needs: if you want maximum flexibility across your stack and are willing to learn Rego, OPA is a strong choice. If you prioritize readability, determinism, and focus specifically on application-level authorization, Cedar may be more suitable. (1) (2)
To learn more, see the sources I considered: [[1] Policy Engine Showdown - OPA vs. OpenFGA vs. Cedar](https://www.permit.io/blog/policy-engine-showdown-opa-vs-openfga-vs-cedar) [[2] Policy Engines: Open Policy Agent vs AWS Cedar vs Google Zanzibar](https://www.permit.io/blog/policy-engines) [[3] OPA, Cedar, OpenFGA: Why are Policy Languages Trending Right Now?](https://www.permit.io/blog/opa-cedar-openfga-why-are-policy-languages-trending)
d
The AI Agent gave a nice answer. Let me know if anything is unclear šŸ™‚