Voting on code review is pretty cool Can we also add the same voting option to individual inline comments in addition to the main review comment?

Shouts out to @red-crayon-20970 for this! Voting on inline suggestions would definitely be a more precise signal. We're working on calibrating the suggestions atm, voting will be a good next step.

Thanks for the feedback @quick-window-91705! Voting on inline suggestions is definitely something that we are interested in!

I haven’t seen how is this implemented, sorry: out of curiosity, is it possible to send a request referencing some other random comment, not the reviewer agent comment, and it will be received and processed?

Our data pipeline is basically scraping all the comments from the review. You can leave thumbs-{up, down} on any of those and we'll be able to find it. (Inline suggestions will really just be a little footer in the comment that has the same "give us feedback" text)

Aha, thank you. Does it scrape other comments, left by a random passerby?

It does. We're using the GH API to grab any comments on the PR, so we can tune the review bot to match human suggestions as much as possible. We've got some data-cleaning going on to ensure we only pick up the "useful" suggestions for this analysis though.

I'd love to see what credentials we use (gh token, llm token, something else?) for an agent that gets the random comments in context. I mean, I’d like to know the credentials names, because this sounds prone to prompt injection, and it would be good to know what the blast radius is, exactly

It's not a pure agentic workflow. We're scraping comments using the Github API, using some LLM-as-judge analysis to extract suggestions and analyze the code, then more manual analysis to process those suggestions. I think the worst a prompt injection attack could do right now is mess with our analysis, but since the end result is just a PR updating a skill we're still manually reviewing any generated changes.

Perfect, thank you!