https://linen.dev logo
That is super coarse, especially for an LES to be ...
# general-help
q
That is super coarse, especially for an LES to be having physical meaning. But ofcourse, this is a very subjective and loose comment on my side. 1. As a starting point, stick to kOmegaSST for now, and consider your PIV level mesh as the coarsest resolution, now do ~1.4-2x in each direction and run again...check the difference in results. Repeat it for a third time... See if your results stop changing with mesh resolution. 2. Does the timeAverage of the LES field correspond well to the RANS field? 3. See if you can quantify the "smaller than what is shown in paper". (I am holding back on comments about behaviour near the free surface: the flat free slip condition may not be most accurate representation BUT it is too early to comment as you need to establish grid sensitivity first before we have confidence in your values) 4. The LES result is not instantaneous, strictly speaking, but yes it is supposed to represent the major chunk of instantaneous motion.. as compared to unsteady RANS which has an inherently averaged nature as conpared to the instantaneous manifestations of the flow..(to simplify: these differences are embedded in the formulae used to close the navier stokes equations using the assumptions of these models) Technically, they are both representative of only a part of the full velocity field, but ideally, a well-done LES would approach the true instantaneous velocity - so it does inherently carry a stronger instantaneous character and something you can consider as a reasonable representation of large scale instantaneous flow (I hope I don't killed by big dogs lopezcastano and zino on this one XD ). So umm do average things for LES when looking against PIV... For starters just simply use temporal Average over many steps in paraview.. I am curious how many cells are there in your domain?