https://linen.dev logo
When it comes to AI in software, I think there is ...
# general-talk
d
When it comes to AI in software, I think there is sometimes a very strong desire by the devs to add it, without really thinking if it's useful. For example, denoising based on machine learning is an amazing tool for photographs. Granted, when it's done by companies like Adobe it's still extremely immoral (stolen artwork, etc.), but there are genuinely good, locally run applications of 'AI tools' (obviously a massive umbrella term). On the other hand there are ways like jamming an LLM into a software that absolutely does not need it (cough cough adobe acrobat reader) which ruin the software. Off the top of my head, I can't really think of many ways OpenFOAM could benefit from anything AI related. Maybe snappyHexMesh could use ML during iterations to improve a mesh, but for it to be useful in any meaningful capacity, you'd need a massive database of good high quality meshes. Would it be possible to ethically source that much data? Doubt it. I've heard from a developer of a different open-source CFD software proudly proclaim that he added the kOmegaSST turbulence model to their code in a mere day using chatGPT, that, I'm very much against. Vibe coding has no place in development, open-source or not. If it were to be used in OpenFOAM development by someone, I'm sure that other contributors would very quickly catch wind and then have to spend valuable time fixing the messy code.