I'm still not personally convinced.
My impression is even though a few people have requested there haven't been anyone willing to actually develop a pipeline (I've advertised in different places as a 'free idea', but no-one has bitten), which makes me wonder how in demand it is.
That said in one of the places where I talked about it, I was pointed to this pipeline:
https://github.com/grp-bork/nHUMAnN
It's not nf-core but from a good group, so I think this would suffice until someone comes up with other competitors to HUMANn3.
I recognise the argument about the complementariness of MetaPhLAn --> HUMANn, I don't think we should break our clearly defined 'scope' (which is one of the things I'm most proud about taxprofiler 😅 - most metagenomics pipelines across bioinformatics so often result in feature creep and end up trying to do
everything...).
taxprofiler is not meant to be a generalised short-read metagenomics pipeline - but very specifically for generating taxonomic profiles - which HUMANn output is not. In otherwords, it's not about the input data but the output data.