I have an old tag of the <#C06TRU74N4D|> pipeline,...
# pipeline-maintainers
c
I have an old tag of the #C06TRU74N4D pipeline,
1.1.1
which crashes with:
Copy code
/bin/bash: line 9: .command.run: Permission denied
I am very surprised, because I think that I remember tha the pipeline worked when I did this release. It may be the same issue as in https://github.com/nf-core/rnaseq/issues/1562. In my case, it has bitten one of my users who chose 1.1.1 when prompted by
nextflow
to pick a revision number (not sure why he picked that one; that was really bad luck). So I wonder what to do: • Wait that a nextflow update solves the problem, or • Release a fix as 1.1.2 and delete 1.1.1, or • Just delete 1.1.1, because users who want 1.1.1 can also be satisfied by either 1.1.0 or 2.0.0...
p
I guess this is this problem. 1. It's an nf-core template problem not Nextflow (even if Nextflow unfortunately hid the bug until recently). So I don't think that it'll ever be fixed in Nextflow. 2. I don't think that you should delete anything. Users can either use an older version of Nextflow or apply a config to overwrite the broken pipeline config. See above message. Generally deleting a version should never be done as it's bad for reproducibility. You can add a big warning to the top of the changelog / release notes for that release if it'd help and other things. Deleting it should be an absolute last resort.
c
Thanks! I will add a message in the next changelog update, and I guess that I can also update the 1.1.1 revision's description in GitHub?
p
Yup 👍🏻
m
I just wanted to confirm that #C06TRU74N4D 1.1.1 is affected by said bug in the pipeline template. For the preview of the new advisories, I sifted through all pipeline releases during that period and manually curated a list of affected pipelines: https://deploy-preview-3366--nf-core-main-site.netlify.app/advisories/pipelines/process-shell-configuration
👌 3
🎉 1
c
Hi @Matthias Zepper I would like to link to the advisory in the pipeline's changelog, but is there a stable URL for it? I guess that
deploy-preview…<http://netlify.app|netlify.app>
is not?
m
No, sadly there is not yet. Advisories are a new feature that I proposed as a consequence of that issue, but which have not yet been merged to the public version of website. I recommend you link to the announcements on Slack instead?
👍 1
By the way: Feedback on that proposal, be it the API specification of the fontmatter (e.g. which categories do you think are relevant) or the look of the components is much appreciated. See the PR with all the technical stuff here and the formal proposal (which is a living document as well) here.