Hi, I have a similar question to Felix's above reg...
# modules
t
Hi, I have a similar question to Felix's above regarding Docker and conda. I created a PR to add a module for UniFIRE (PR #8075: https://github.com/nf-core/modules/pull/8075) and got feedback about creating a bioconda package. And so I'm wondering if that is strictly necessary. Here is the link to UniFIRE's docs: https://gitlab.ebi.ac.uk/uniprot-public/unifire. I'm not the creator of the tool, and I don't know if there is any plan to add a bioconda package anytime soon.
j
You can make an issue to ask if you have the developers permission
If you're unsure
The licence seems to indicate there would be no issue with doing it afaik
o
Hi @James Fellows Yates, the UniProt team has only created a Docker image for UniFire (https://gitlab.ebi.ac.uk/uniprot-public/unifire), and no conda package. For #proteinannotator, we are using this UniFire process (https://github.com/EBI-Metagenomics/mettannotator/blob/a70e121334cf4ed14957a133d58dc806bcdac1c7/modules/local/unifire.nf) as recommended by @Martin Beracochea, who said that the UniProt team is working on creating bioconda packages but probably won’t get to it for a while (https://nfcore.slack.com/archives/C084HP11VPF/p1742848476903309). UniFire is a pretty hefty package and I think creating a bioconda package will be quite the heavy lift
πŸ‘ 1
m
Hiya πŸ‘‹ . The devs work at EBI (somewhere in my building I think). I think the easiest would be for me approach them and see if the can help with the conda package. How does it sound?
πŸ‘ 1
I think they are going to be just fine with "us" getting the tool packages as a conda thingy.
j
Would be great @Martin Beracochea! Thank you!
I think as we can maybe just about trust EBI for stability πŸ˜‰ we can let the conda/buocuonda/quay io rule slide here and just use the EBIS docker container for now
m
nice. I can use this as an argument... look, people want to use the tool... let's create a conda package
❀️ 2
the same applies to interproscan
just to manage expectations.. I'm going to away for most of April, so I don't think I'll make much progress (other than slacking some people).
j
You can say there are a lot of volunteers Willing to try as well so if it's a time issue they can do the bulk of the initial work
meow yes 1
o
I think @Ken Brewer might be looking at the InterProScan recipe
πŸ‘ 1
j
I had thought someone told me at some point there was some license issue with interproscan but I don't remember now
Maybe my brain is making it up
o
Some tools that InterProScan can call require additional special licenses, see: https://interproscan-docs.readthedocs.io/en/v5/ActivatingLicensedAnalyses.html
I think the bioconda version avoids this issue by just not including the tools that require special licenses, which I think is fine. If someone gets those licenses, they can modify the module locally to add them
πŸ‘ 1
j
Ok cool!