Lately, I have been working a lot with GATK module...
# modules
f
Lately, I have been working a lot with GATK modules. I must say, the FASTA and FAI input conventions seem unstandardised and quite confusing when passing files from one process to another. Take for example GATK4_COMPOSESTRTABLEFILE (only takes only path for FASTA), GATK4_ADDORREPLACEREADGROUPS (takes tuples for both FAI, FASTA), GATK4_MARKDUPLICATES (takes only paths for both FAI, FASTA). Considering that these processes are often interconnected, what's the rationale for having to drop and re-introduce metadata (explicitly modifying channels) for the same tool within a workflow?
m
Hi @Fredrick, inconsistency is mainly to the fact that agreed on some solution, and later updated it, but not all modules have caught up with it, we're thinking of another solution still, and I totally agree that it would be amazing to have more consistency there
👍 2
f
I seem to be making progress. Thanks for the clarification
m
I have been meaning to talk to Ben (one of the main Nextflow dev about it), and I will hopefully report back with a plan for it for the next #team-maintainers meeting
👀 1