Edmund
01/08/2025, 4:40 PMMaxime Garcia
01/08/2025, 4:44 PMMaxime Garcia
01/08/2025, 4:52 PMMatthias Zepper
01/08/2025, 6:02 PMDoes that mean we don’t need https://github.com/nf-core/modules/pull/7260?It appears there are additional updates in the PR, such as modifications to the conda’s
environment.yml, which could still be relevant. However, there is no longer a strict requirement to replace oras:// container declarations in modules, as Tools 3.1 now provides* basic* support for them.
That said, I would greatly appreciate continued efforts towards the initial plan for properly adopting Seqera Containers, namely a dedicated container.yml / container section in meta.yml within the pipeline repository. That file could be parsed by nf-core pipelines download for architecture-specific downloads.
Currently, nf-core download cannot consolidate native Singularity and Docker images. As a result, in addition to the native Singularity images, it also downloads all Docker images of Seqera Containers and converts them to Singularity images. This means that for an average pipeline, you will download ~25 superfluous container images. From the Download perspective, Bioconda/Biocontainer images thus remain the preferred option over Seqera Containers, but if you choose them for your modules, the oras:// protocol is now supported as well.Phil Ewels
01/08/2025, 6:57 PMPhil Ewels
01/08/2025, 6:57 PMHowever, there are some downsides:
• Shared cache Nextflow options such asand$NXF_SINGULARITY_CACHEDIRare not used$NXF_SINGULARITY_LIBRARYDIR
• Singularity must be installed when downloading images for offline use
•is only supported by recent versions of Singularity / Apptaineroras://
Phil Ewels
01/08/2025, 6:57 PMMaxime Garcia
01/08/2025, 7:18 PMMaxime Garcia
01/08/2025, 7:18 PMEdmund
01/08/2025, 7:19 PMMatthias Zepper
01/08/2025, 7:34 PMEdmund
01/08/2025, 7:35 PMMatthias Zepper
01/08/2025, 7:39 PMLeon Hafner
01/08/2025, 8:06 PMMaxime Garcia
01/08/2025, 8:12 PMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:39 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:40 AMMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 8:43 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:45 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:45 AMMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 8:47 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:48 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:48 AM-profile singluarity or -profile singularity_orasPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 8:48 AMMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 8:50 AMcontainer.yml and deal with it nicelyMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 8:50 AMMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 8:50 AMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 4:13 PMMaxime Garcia
01/09/2025, 4:13 PMPhil Ewels
01/09/2025, 4:15 PM