This message was deleted.
# helpdesks
steep-balloon-41261
10/19/2022, 9:41 AMThis message was deleted.
c
clever-motorcycle-90824
10/19/2022, 5:45 PMre: the STUN issue, have you tried just explicitly specifying STUN servers in your config?
d
dry-elephant-14928
10/19/2022, 9:27 PMinteresting use case with 1. previously it advertised both private and public IP as a side-effect; it was not intentional. I think @early-gigabyte-44411 improved upon that behavior in master, that's yet unreleased. I'm not sure if it'll advertise both private and public IPs at the same time.
that said, your use case is an interesting one and I hope we'll be able to support TURN servers that can go through the private IP address. Could you file an issue in GH for this?
2. with forceRelay, a new change was merged yesterday that would honor client-side settings instead of overriding it. So I think this should do what you are looking for?
e
early-gigabyte-44411
10/20/2022, 1:51 AMThe server side switch transport to
relayrelaymore controlalldirectrelayrelaydirectf
few-night-99427
10/20/2022, 3:45 PM@clever-motorcycle-90824 yes, but that does not make any diference, because the we do not go inside the else statement here: https://github.com/livekit/livekit/blob/master/pkg/rtc/config.go#L197
few-night-99427
10/20/2022, 4:00 PM@dry-elephant-14928 as for 1., sure Im going to create one.
As for 2: an easy fix could be to move this if statement: https://github.com/livekit/client-sdk-js/blob/08fcc156f9fb83eb3648e9db1ab10a50d1568bac/src/room/RTCEngine.ts#L263 inside the condition above because if I want to use my previously provided ice servers then probably I’d want to control the forceRelay flag as well, otherwise Livekit’s decision is acceptable. I have scenarios where I want to tell the client, it must use relay because of several reasons, not just because the webrtc connectivity.
few-night-99427
10/20/2022, 4:03 PM@early-gigabyte-44411 I think my scenario is the opposite: I know that relay is more stable then public - because of the network setup. In a single cluster setup it does not make improvement, but with multiregion, world-wide rooms, TURN could be leveraged to have better connection than the direct connection.
d
dry-elephant-14928
10/20/2022, 5:38 PM@few-night-99427 if you are passing in forceRelay, it will be honored. are you saying you'd want to keep forceRelay to
off➕ 1
e
early-gigabyte-44411
10/21/2022, 1:09 AMIt should not be override if you set policy to
relayf
few-night-99427
10/21/2022, 6:59 PMthe point is that ice servers can be set from client and the client will not update it from the joinresponse - thanks to the
!rtcConfig.iceServersiceTransportPolicyiceTransportPolicyiceTransportPolicy