I am bearish on both Discord and Telegram tbh (but only for now, maybe situation will change for the better soon)
I've seen some projects like Miden (another privacy L2) who have decided not to make a DC community but rather a TG community. And it's not any different from DC but it is also missing many of DC's key aspects. I will always prefer DC to TG anyway
As for DC servers being overrun by sybils - that's a completely different topic of discussion. Sybils are usually pointless in discord and will result in nothing. There's a much bigger problem these days = DC servers are mostly overrun not by sybils but by
designated farming groups. How does that work:
1. A guy who made some money in crypto "invests" that money and hires a bunch of high school kids/university students whom he pays very little every month so they "chat and make content" in some project's Discord. Content is made with either AI or with some cheap piece of shit art-making tool purchased for $3
2. He delegates 10-20-30 accounts to them and they basically work for him
3. Their main goal is to "get roles" in the project's community Discord
4. He will collect all the rewards from those roles on TGE (if there is a reward) and these hired students will receive a % from that reward
That's how it usually works these days. Inco (just like many other project's discord) is now being overrun by those same people that "farm" in many other places.
Now the question is = how to stop this? Answer = you really can't. People will always find a way to game the system, doesn't matter if it's DC or telegram. Telegram groups will eventually end in the same way, gamed cheated and manipulated with bots/hired accounts/sybils/etc
I still think that having DC roles is
good. That way you can recognize true and genuine community members. How to make sure that roles are NOT given to the wrong people? My only suggestion at this point is that every project should have a designated team who checks content, verifies everything including chat history and overall activity in the server. Roles should be HARD to get. Maybe only 5-10 people should be given roles every month. Once the farmers realize how
hard it is to earn a role, most of them will give up and leave. As a result = yes, there will be a lot of criticism, FUD and crying in the chat. But the project who truly wants to only recognize true contributors should just ignore all that. Many other things that can be done but at this point I'm tired of writing lol