Hey Gary. I am still not entirely sure what exactly is happening, but here’s the summary: In GitHub, we have explicitly enabled merge commits, squash merging, and rebase merging. However, when I tried to do a regular merge for the PR, I received a 500 error from Graphite with the message (in the console) “merge commits are not allowed in this repository”. I then checked GitHub, and it too permits squash or rebase merging for the PR only. The only issue in Graphite is that the UI allows me to attempt a type of merge — in our case, a regular merge commit — that GitHub does not allow.