Hey guys, first, thank you for making an awesome p...
# report-bugs
e
Hey guys, first, thank you for making an awesome product, Graphite has revolutionized the way i work and think about git. I have a question about the Graphite + Linear integration: When graphite's merge queue completes and successfully merges the stack, the merged PRs go into
closed
and not
merged
. Linear automation doesn't recognize the "closed" PRs as being done and the issues (Linear task) stay hanging, I need to close it manually. In theory, i think it's between Linear and Github, it doesn't necessarily involves the graphite's integration, but i am asking both parties if anyone had experiencies similar to mine. Thanks!
p
(If applicable) To help us repro, please send the following if you haven't already: - PR links, screenshots, and/or debug output if applicable - Repro steps - Does this happen consistently? Just to you or others on your team also? - Is this a regression? Is the problem new? - If you're having an issue with the CLI, please send us debug logs using
gt feedback --with-debug-context <any message>
b
Yes, this has been by far the biggest drawback of enabling the merge queue for us.
e
I got in contact with Graphite's support by e-mail and they told me it was a known issue. I just hope it get's solved.
p
Apologies that this has been a rough experience, the team's looking into this one. Will hopefully have more news soon
d
Bumping this : ) Top QoL request from my team!
👍 1
b
So many things break because of this. Github’s automatic release notes show no changes now because nothing is “merged”.
I feel like one possible solution would be a “true merge” option. I can imagine this working is by merging down PRs from the top of the stack into their parents until it finally merges into main. This would also restore things like Linear merge triggers.
👍 1
e
FYI @Dhruvik Parikh and @Bilal Quadri, I disabled the "Optimize Merge" option, and now instead of squash and merging the stack, it merges 1 by 1. The PRs correctly go into
merge
instead of
closed
and all of other integrations work. I payed for integrations with CI time.
👍 1
d
Yup that makes sense, but ideally it doesn't have to be a tradeoff haha.
I saw @Bilal Quadri suggested a neat idea to fold the changes one by one and still do the final merge together. If that doesn't work for some reason, I'd imagine the cross-usage between Graphite and Linear is so high that it might be justified to build some bespoke hook that replaces the functionality...