This message was deleted.

hmm, can you dm me a PR that this happens for? will look into it

yeah!

Hey! So this is actually due to a weird behavior of GitHub where reply-only reviews don't show up in the timeline (and so we don't show them in our timeline either, because their timeline API response matches their timeline). We actually have a workaround for this for replies created in Graphite where we create an empty review so that it does show up in the timeline, which is why your first reply does actually show up in the timeline here. Obviously, we have the data in the thread even though it isn't in the timeline, so I wonder if we might be able to start looking for cases like this and injecting them into our timeline view. cc @kush and @David Bradford