I'm surprised that they still don't seem to use an...
# right-capital
n
I'm surprised that they still don't seem to use an API for Ally (Ally appears to have one). I'm hesitant to give my asset credentials over to any 3rd party, no matter the level of trust, because I believe it's a violation of of TOS with Ally and could leave me liable in the event of a breach. For non-assets (e.g., credit cards), I don't care, since I don't see any serious damage a hacker can do. Thoughts?
plus1 1
m
Reach out to them!
You can add ally accounts in manually also in the meantime.
If you're really nervous.
n
I plan to contact them. Last time I logged in, I did not immediately see any easy way to contact them, but will look more carefully next time.
Relevant section of the TOS
m
If you write up an email and send to me baruch@frum.finance I can send it to their customer support. We pay for streamlined support.
Your client, Yehuda Davis, recently reached out asking if RightCapital stores login credentials when using the account aggregation feature. Per company policy we are unable to communicate directly with clients however, I'll be happy to pass along some information that you can share with your client. If there are any security concerns from the client, you can send this link (https://www.rightcapital.com/security) to them as it highlights our security measures. The Data Security section specifically discusses how we partner with Yodlee for account aggregation and we (RightCapital) do not store any of your client credentials. We communicate with Yodlee via an encrypted data link. You can also send this link (https://www.yodlee.com/clients-customers/) to Yodlee's website to your clients.
n
Okay, yeah, I meant them or their partners. Point is, I'm sharing my creds with a third party. Guess I would have to reach out to yodlee. Maybe they'll send an email to RightCapital saying that one of their clients' clients reached out... 😉 Meanwhile, I applied for an API from Ally so I can see the process. Then maybe I can get yodlee on board
m
Yeah I mean I think the point is right capital has hands that are tied and you should contact yodlee.
👍 1
s
Building on this point, it seems like there are two types of login flows when connected banks. One give a pop-up and takea you to your banks site, while one leaves it embedded or the like. It seems like that is what is being discussed here. What I'm finding interesting is that the embedded version is being used even with banks that they seem to have an established relationship with, like PNC. Any thoughts? Thanks
m
Are you claiming that one is more secure than the other?
s
It definitely feels like it, one you are on the bank's own site, one you aren't. But I don't know what's going on under the hood
m
Depending on the internals I can imagine making a strong case in both directions that it's more secure
It's worth discussing with the company that does all the integrations, yodelle
They are massive. Right capital doesn't call the shots here.
s
Right It's probably a matter that can be researched, of if they have an official partnership with the bank or if they are jeryrigging the connection
m
Agreed. Either way I just blindly login. I work in cyber security and there are so many lower bars to steal my bank creds it's not worth worrying about it for me lol.
s
Fair enough 🙂
👍 1
n
My argument is more from a legal perspective. If someone steals my creds, it's the bank's problem. If I give my creds away and then they get stolen, it is possibly my problem. If you're inputting into the bank's own site, it can't be violating their TOS.
m
I don't think you'd be willing to spend the money either way to defend any of this in court anyway if the bank isn't taking achriyus. Even if you have a stronger case bc you didn't put your creds in a bad site, you're going to hire a lawyer to make the bank take achriyus?
n
Probably not, but if Yodlee gets hacked, they may decide not to take responsibility, whereas if I randomly get hacked, they probably would. On a separate note, I did not see any obvious way to contact Yodlee as the client of a client...
m