6,000 notifications sent, 6 subscriptions so far
# general
o
6,000 notifications sent, 6 subscriptions so far
a
Have we sent it to all 25k already? If not, I've been thinking that we can stop now, and for another group come up with new notification text and make a few changes on a paywall to see the conversion
o
8k so far
Yeah happy to test any other copy
a
Great! So we can stop for now, I’ll create a few more paywalls and notification copies tomorrow, and we can run a few more tests with the rest of the audience. How does it sound?
o
Sounds good!
a
https://www.notion.so/getclearspace/Changes-in-toast-paywall-notification-6a64391490e74ebdbd6b72d34b75133c?pvs=4 here are some small changes that could improve our CR to paid let me know what you think! @oliver @royce
o
Yep! Can make these changes and send out the next batch. My only edits is the nails emoji - feels irrelevant to the message, is there some lingo I don't know about?
a
we can replace it with 🔥
can we send these changes to only 5000 users?
o
sure
💥 1
I wish I had attached a notification ID or something to the mixpanel event so we'd be able to differentiate easily between this batch and the last batch
but the best way to measure in mixpanel will just be date+time that
paywallNotiReceived
occurred
a
maybe we can just sort them by days? 👀
👍 1
o
what about 🎈 or 📦 for emoji?
I like using something less common
To grab attention and because I think fire is becoming a bit stale with younger people like 😂 became stale
a
yeah you are right…
I’d use some gen z emoji
o
👁️‍🗨️
lol
what are some other good ones
a
🤣
o
8 purchases yesterday btw
student discount purchases I mean
a
we need moooore! 😈
💥 1
o
Toast looks good with changes but there is a bit too much text for the notification
IMG_0260.jpeg
Some alternative options:
r
87% discount to $9.99/year for students. Offer ends in 12 hours!
o
IMG_0265.jpeg
I like getting in the value prop of "block more apps". If someone doesn't insta-recognize our logo this is just generic sale to them
👍 1
a
I'd add “block more apps” just to test on this small cohort 🙏 If they don't recognize our logo — “student deal” will sound as a generic sale as well Or as an alternative Block More Apps: Student Deal It should fit the title character limit
o
Yeah send me exact text I'll show you how it looks. Proposal is: Title: Block More Apps: Student Deal Body: Clearspace Premium only $9.99/year. Block more than 2 apps and boost focus. Offer ends in 12 hours! ?
a
We can shorten the body to: Get Clearspace Premium only $9.99/year. Offer ends in 12 hours! ⏳
o
IMG_0266.jpeg
a
Looks nice to me!
o
Cool will send to the next 5k
🚀 1
r
what if everyone signs up
that'd be so cool
🙂
o
50k dollars 🙂
we buy a tiger
for the office
r
and get sushi for dinner
but not the terrible doordash sushi
good sushi
o
Starting the run for the next 5k
🚀 1
ahh wait
need to update the paywall to your proposal
ok done
CleanShot 2024-06-04 at 12.48.27.png
starting the run 🙂
a
let’s gooo!
results of the experiment are here: https://www.notion.so/getclearspace/Student-Discount-Experiment-results-and-next-hypotheses-c8a9fd5128284e42ba44cb5ab2e8296c?pvs=4 good news: CR to paid increased x2 but, CR to notification or toast tap decreased so here I see two options: 1. We can test other text options and run for the next 5000 2. We can take our old texts and run with current paywall for 5000 What do you think? @oliver @royce
o
Let's go with existing paywall, new notification text and toast text
I want to try simpler messaging in notification and toast. My hypothesis is • lots of text in the notification makes it less likely to be read • using the cents price per day in the toast makes people less likely to realize this is actually a great deal I'm going to run 5k with • Notification ◦ Title: Student Deal 🫶 ◦ Body: $10 for a year of Clearspace Premium. Unlock all features • Toast: ◦ 💸 Student Discount 💸 ◦ Clearspace Premium is just $9.99/year. Offer ends in 12 hours
a
Looks great!!!
o
👍 running
a
Results: https://www.notion.so/getclearspace/Student-Discount-Experiment-3-e66f84d4f64947478c1f8e16dd1aac07?pvs=4 I think now we can leave toast and the paywall as they show great CR, but send the same notification that we sent 06.03 where CR to tap was 9.35% What do you think? @oliver
o
Yes sounds good, will send out the last ~8k with that strategy today
closing the loop on this experiment • we've had 43 total student discount purchases • 39 of them came from people we sent notifications to The last batch went out today, so I think we should give it until Saturday, then remove the 9.99 product from the App Store so it doesn't get used by non-students.
@royce @Anastasiia what do you think?
r
nice - yeah that sounds good
will removing the product from the store cause issues for existing users though?
esp when they renew?
o
good q I'm not sure let me find out
CleanShot 2024-06-06 at 17.27.39.png
looks like if we do that they will not be able to renew
but we might save more money by just giving them all lifetime in RC and removing 9.99 price
let's say 50% of those 43 people renew for the next 5 years (very optimistic). That's (43 / 2) * 10 * 5 = $1075 of future revenue If we lose 27 would-be purchasers in that same time (IE people who would have paid full price but are savvy enough to find the discount), that's also $1075. (27 * $40 ) (using $40 as the diff in price between annual and student discount) Seems likely to me that we'd lose 27 would-be purchasers in the next 5 years. Math holds for shorter projections too (IE 1 year in the future = $215 projected student discount revenue, seems equally likely we'd lose 215/40 = 5 would-be purchasers in that 1 year)
TLDR - I think we pull the product and give lifetime to everyone that bought it
👍 1
a
Do you think we should communicate with them about it?