Oh, I actually meant being angry as editor #1 who accepted the piece and then couldn’t put it out, but yeah, if editor #1 ignores the withdrawal and publishes first, then yes, editor #2 would be justifiably angry (to a lesser extent, if #1 publishes second but within the exclusivity window or without crediting magazine #2).
Without implying, Ethan, that you did anything wrong, I don’t like sending work to inexperienced mastheads.