aloha folks. I'm toying with ServiceManager to sta...
# generala
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:38 AMaloha folks. I'm toying with ServiceManager to start 3-in-1. such that controller, server and broker start as one
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:38 AMworks, but what I noticed is that this is individually starting services (ex not trunking them over one port). This makes things like Docker HEALTHCHECK an interesting thing
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:39 AMex if you do some commands you'll get a 400 if server is not up. I'm wondering if there's a good HTTP path that can show that server + broker are functional, or if it is safe to assume that if you check broker that server is also functional
k
Kishore G
08/12/2020, 5:46 AM
I thought the servicemanager has a different port
Kishore G
08/12/2020, 5:46 AM
and doing health check on that should return good only if all the the configured roles are up and running
👍 1
a
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:46 AMyeah but I think the stuff starts individually. checking SM port != checking the other ports right?
k
Kishore G
08/12/2020, 5:47 AM
if thats not the case, we should add that
a
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:48 AMI'll look at the code, but main thing is in a pipeline we'd have an awesome time for a single HEALTHCHECK ack this is hard to muster when an image can be used different ways
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:49 AMbut it is also possible that by reading the same config or otherwise an effective healthcheck can be built. right now I'm mainly trying to solve a late 400 err
k
Kishore G
08/12/2020, 5:50 AM
Got it, @Xiang Fu should probably have more info, lets create an issue and continue the discussion there?
👍 1
a
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:50 AMI'll do it!
k
Kishore G
08/12/2020, 5:51 AM
thats for pointing this issue, we want to make all in one service as the default way to start pinot going forward
a
Adrian Cole
08/12/2020, 5:53 AM