Are

async-http-client-1.9.21.jar

and

calcite-core-1.34.0.jar

still required for

pinot-jdbc-client-1.0.0

? I removed them and the JDBC client did not have any problems. The docs only update as far as

pinot-jdbc-shaded-0.13.0-SNAPSHOT.jar

https://docs.pinot.apache.org/integrations/tableau#install-pinot-jdbc-for-tableau-desktop

in my work trying to slim down the shaded jar (https://github.com/timveil-startree/pinot-jdbc-uber-jar) i have continued to include those jars... in other words i believe those to be required.

Roger that thank you 🙇

so i use the existing dependency graph for the

pinot-jdbc-client

module and then do a few things... 1) i exclude certain transitive dependencies that i've determined to be unnecessary or unwanted. a good example of this is duplicative or old logging dependencies 2) i overwrite additional dependencies to fix versions or re-include dependencies that were unintentionally excluded.

That makes sense. I am wondering why I do not see

async-http-client-1.9.21.jar

?

as for

async-http

it is already included as a transitive dependency of

pinot-jdbc-client

that i neither excluded or modified so its not in my pom file

Ahh 👍

the version of calcite bundled with pinot 1.0.0 is

1.30.0

as found here... https://mvnrepository.com/artifact/org.apache.pinot/pinot-common/1.0.0

That version actually doe NOT work with the JDBC connector

let me review this part of the documentation... there may have been something unique to the tableau configuration

And the version in your uber jar is 1.36.0 https://github.com/timveil-startree/pinot-jdbc-uber-jar/blob/main/pom.xml#L24

so this is where things get a bit complicated... my uber jar uses the latest pinot

1.1.0

snapshot which has been updated to use a more recent version of calcite (and other dependencies). i'm still working thru a mechanism to more properly align versions of my uber jar with released versions of pinot but for now this mismatch exists.

Pinot 1.0.0

very good. let me work on that for you

And the idea is we won't need external

calcite-core

and

async-http-client

jars?

for my uber jar, i attempt to bundle all classes required by the driver into the jar so no additional jars should be needed except perhaps a logging implementation jar. having said that my tests with my uber jar were focused on tools like IntelliJ/DataGrip/DBeaver/DBVisualizer. I have not tested with Tableau but i would very much like to

Do you all have an internal Tableau to test with? I think it needs to be tested on Tableau server

let me tag @Vibhuti Bhushan who may be able to shed light on the current state of the official tableau work

I can help with a tableau license. To connect tableau with ST, users will need JDBC jar file and a TCO file. Here are the instructions to connect: https://dev.startree.ai/docs/get-started-with-startree-cloud/connect-to-startree-cloud/connect-tableau-to-startree-cloud @Jessica Stewart if you can share your email-id, I will check if i can add you to the license to access Tableau

I don't think this is answering the correct question? I was asking Tim if he is able to test his uber jar with Tableau so I think the test resources would need to go to him?

@Jessica Stewart and @Tim Veil did you find out which Version

async-http-client.jar

and

calcite-core.jar

is required for

pinot-jdbc-client-1.0.0

or rather the direct connection to Pinot Version 1.0.0?